A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraphs 22.1–22.4

Chapter XXII. Of Lawful Oaths and Vows

The subjects treated of in these Sections are—(a.) The nature of a lawful oath. (b.) The only name in which it is lawful to swear. (c.) The propriety and duty of taking oaths upon the proper occasions. (d.) The sense in which an oath is to be interpreted. And (e) The extent and grounds of its binding obligation.

1st. A lawful oath consists in calling upon God, the occasion being of sufficient seriousness and importance, to witness the truth of what we affirm as true, or our voluntary assumption of an obligation to do something in the future—with an implied imprecation of God’s disfavour if we lie or prove unfaithful to our engagements. This last is generally expressed by the phrase forming the concluding part of the formula of most oaths, “So help me God,” i. e., Let God so help me as I have told the truth, or as I will keep my promise.

Hence an oath is an act of supreme religious worship, since it recognizes the omnipresence, omniscience, absolute justice and sovereignty of the person whose august witness is invoked, and whose judgment is appealed to as final.

2d. It hence follows that it is a sin equivalent to that of worshipping a false god if we swear by any other than the only true and living God, and a sin of idolatry if we swear by any thing or place, although it be associated with the true God. Those who swear with uplifted hand swear by the God who created, preserves and governs all things. Those who swear with hands upon or kissing the Bible, swear by the God who reveals himself in the Bible—that is, by the true Christian God. It is evident that none who believe in the true God can, consistently with their integrity, swear by a false god. And it is no less evident that it is dishonest for an atheist to go through the form of swearing at all, or for an infidel to swear with his hand upon the Christian Scriptures, thereby professing to invoke a God in whose existence he does not believe.

This principle is fully recognized in Scripture. We are told to swear by the true God: “Unto me every knee shall bow and every tongue shall swear,” Isa. xlv. 23; “He that sweareth in the earth shall swear by the God of truth,” Isa. lxv. 16; “Thou shalt fear Jehovah thy God and serve him, and swear by his name,” Deut. vi. 13. We are forbidden to swear by the name of false gods: “How shall I pardon thee for this? Thy children have forsaken me and sworn by them that are no gods.” Jer. v. 7; Josh. xxiii. 7.

3d. The literal meaning of the Third Commandment is, “Thou shalt not take the name of thy God in that which is false”—that is, to confirm an untruth. The command not to take a false oath or any oath upon a trifling occasion, by implication carries with it the permission to call upon the God of truth to confirm the truth upon all worthy occasions. Hence the oath is enjoined in the Old Testament as a recognized religious institution. Deut. vi. 13; x. 20, etc. Christ himself, when put upon oath in the form common among the Jews, did not hesitate to answer. Matt. xxvi. 63, 64. Paul often appeals to God for the truth of his statements—thus: “God is my witness;” “I call God for a record upon my soul.” Rom. i. 9; 2 Cor. i. 23. In Hebrews (Heb. vi. 13–18) Paul declares that God, in order “to show unto the heirs of the promise the immutability of his counsel, confirms it by an oath;” and, “because he could swear by no greater, he swears by himself.”

It is evident, therefore, that the words of our Saviour (Matt. v. 33–37), “Swear not at all,” cannot be intended to forbid swearing upon proper occasions in the name of the true God, but must be designed to forbid the calling upon his name in ordinary conversation on trifling occasions, and the swearing by that which is not God.

The proper occasions upon which an oath may be taken are all those in which serious and perfectly lawful interests are involved, and in which an appeal to the witness of God is necessary to secure confidence and end strife (Heb. vi. 16), and also whenever the oath is imposed by competent authority upon those subject to it. In the last case, our Confession says that the taking the oath is a duty and its refusal a sin.

The oath of course, both because of its nature as an act of divine worship and because of the effect designed to be attained by it—namely, the establishment of confidence among men—ought always to be administered and taken in a reverend manner, and with whatever outward action—such as raising the hand, placing it upon the Scriptures or kissing them—as by common consent are generally understood, by all parties and witnesses, to signify that the God appealed to is the true God of creation, providence and the Christian revelation.

4th. The oath is always to be interpreted and kept sacred by the person taking it, in the sense in which he honestly believes that it is understood by the person who imposes it. It is evident that if the government, the judge, the magistrate or a private fellow-citizen require an oath from us for their satisfaction, and if we put a private sense upon the matter upon which we invoke the witness of God different from that which we know they understand by it, that we deceive them intentionally, and, by calling God to witness our truth while we are engaged in the very act of a lie, we commit the sin of perjury.

5th. The obligation of the oath arises (a) out of the original and universal obligation to speak the truth and to keep faith in all engagements; (b) and, in addition to this, our obligation to honour God, and to avoid dishonouring him by invoking his witness to a falsehood. (c.) The profanity involved in suspending our hopes of God’s favour upon the truth of that which we know and intend to be false.

An oath cannot bind to that which is in itself unlawful, because the obligation of the law is imposed upon us by the will of God, and therefore takes precedence of all obligations imposed upon us by the will of men or by ourselves; and the lesser obligation cannot relieve from the greater. The sin is in taking the oath to do the unlawful thing, not in breaking it. Therefore Luther was right in breaking his monastic vows. Neither can an oath to do that which is impossible bind, for its impossibility is an expression of the will of God.

But an oath to do what is in itself right and binding imposes an additional obligation to perform it—the obligation imposed by the law, and the obligation voluntarily assumed by ourselves. And an oath to do anything which is lawful binds both for truth’s sake and for God’s sake. And (1) this obligation evidently does not depend upon the goodness or badness of the persons imposing the oath. An oath to an infidel or a heretic binds as much as an oath to a saint. The Romanists excuse the practice of their Church of releasing persons from the obligation of oaths to infidels or heretics, and of breaking faith generally with all with whom she has controversy, on the plea that an oath cannot bind to that which is unlawful or release from a prior obligation, and that the highest of all obligations is to subserve at all cost the interest of the Church. But they deliberately make the oath in order to break it, and therefore both lie and profane God’s holy name in the making and the breaking. Besides, the interest of the Church is not the superior law which takes precedence of all oaths, but the clearly revealed will of God only.

(2.) The obligation of the oath binds even when a man swears to his own disadvantage. Ps. xv. 4.

(3.) Nor is the obligation impaired when the oath is extorted either by violence or fraud. Thus the oaths imposed by conquerors upon the vanquished bind, because they are voluntarily assumed in preference to the alternatives presented. And thus Joshua kept the oath which the Gibeonites had induced him through deceit to swear in their behalf. Joshua ix. 3–29.1

1 Dr. Charles Hodge’s Lectures on the Law.