A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraph 28.4

Chapter XXVIII. Of Baptism

As to the subjects of baptism, our Standards teach—

1st. As to adults, “Baptism is not to be administered to any that are out of the visible Church, and so strangers from the covenant of promise, till they profess their faith in Christ and obedience to him.” L. Cat., Q. 166, and S. Cat. Q. 95.

This is of course self-evident, since the intelligent and honest reception of baptism itself obviously involves precisely this profession of faith in Christ and obedience to him. And in order to secure this, the usage of the Presbyterian Church requires that the pastors and church session should inform the applicant that only a person who has experienced the grace of regeneration, and who has consequently truly repented of sin and exercised faith in Christ, can honestly do what all necessarily profess to do when they are baptized. And to this end the pastor and session must require of the applicant the evidence (a) of a competent knowledge of the fundamental truths of Christianity, and of the nature and binding obligation of baptism; (b) of the fact that he makes a consistent profession of a personal experimental faith and promise of obedience to the Lord, and of due subjection to the constituted authorities of the Church; (c) of the fact that his outward walk and conversation do not belie his profession. After this, the entire responsibility of the step must lie upon the person making it. The church officers have no authority to sit in judgment upon the genuineness of his Christian character, because God has given to no class of men the ability to judge aright of such matters. Some churches, as, for instance, our Covenanting Presbyterian brethren, demand, as a condition of adult baptism—or, what is the same thing, admission to the Church—in addition to the profession of faith in the fundamental truths of the gospel, adherence to certain “testimonies” embodying non-fundamental denominational peculiarities. This we believe to be entirely unauthorized. The Church is Christ’s fold, designed for all his sheep. Baptism and the Lord’s Supper are the common rights of all the Lord’s people. If any man holds the fundamentals of the gospel and professes allegiance to our common Lord, and acts consistently therewith, we have no right to exclude him from his Father’s house. It is just as presumptuous to make terms of communion which Christ has not made as it would be to make terms of salvation which he does not require.

2d. As to infants, our Standards teach that an infant, one or both of whose parents is a believer (Conf. Faith, chap. xxviii., § 4)—i. e., one or both of whose parents profess faith in Christ and obedience to him (L. Cat., Q. 166)—is to be baptized. A bare outline of the abundant scriptural evidence of this truth may be stated as follows:

(1.) In constituting human nature and ordaining the propagation of infant children from parents, God has in all respects made the standing of the child while an infant to depend upon that of the parent. The sin of the parent carries away the infant from God; so the faith of the parent brings the infant near to God.

(2.) Every covenant God has ever formed with mankind has included the child with the parent—e. g., the covenants formed with Adam, Noah (Gen. viii. 9–17), Abraham (Gen. xii. 2, 3; xvii. 7), with Israel through Moses (Ex. xx. 5), and again (Deut. xxix. 10–13); and in the opening sermon of the New Testament dispensation men are exhorted to repent and believe, because the “promise (covenant) is to you and to your children,” etc. Acts ii. 38, 39.

(3.) The Old Testament Church is the same as the New Testament Christian Church. (a.) Paul says (Gal. iii. 8) that the covenant made with Abraham (Gen. xvii. 7) is the “gospel;” and in the whole Epistle to the Hebrews he shows that the Old Testament ritual was a setting forth of the person and work of Christ. See above, under Chapter vii. (b.) Faith was the condition of salvation then as well as now. Abraham believed God, and it was imputed to him for righteousness (Rom. iv. 3), so that he was the great typical believer, “the father of all them that believe” (Rom. iv. 11), and all who believe in Christ “are Abraham’s seed and heirs according to the promise.” Gal. iii. 29. See also the eleventh chapter of Hebrews. All the Israelites, even those only “according to the flesh,” professed to believe. And all “true” Israelites did believe. “He is not a Jew which is one outwardly, neither is that circumcision which is outward in the flesh. But he is a Jew that is one inwardly; and circumcision is that of the heart, in the spirit and not in the letter.” Rom. ii. 28, 29. (c.) Circumcision, precisely in the same sense and to the same extent as baptism, represented a spiritual grace and bound to a spiritual profession. This is taught in the Old Testament, as witness Deut. xiv. 16; xxx. 6. It was the seal of the Abrahamic covenant, which Paul says is the gospel. It was the seal of the righteousness of faith. Rom. ii. 28, 29; iv. 11. True circumcision unites to Christ and secures all the benefits of his redemption. Col. ii. 10, 11. And baptism has now taken the precise place of circumcision: “For as many of you as have been baptized unto Christ have put on Christ, and if ye be Christ’s, then ye are Abraham’s seed and heirs, according to the promise.” Gal. iii. 27, 29. (d.) This Church is identically the same with the New Testament Church. It has the same foundation, the same condition of membership, faith and obedience, sacraments of the same spiritual significancy and binding force. The ancient prophecies declare that the same old Church is to be enlarged, not changed. Isa. xlix. 13–23; lx. 1–14. The ancient covenant which was the fundamental charter of the Church included “many nations” (Gen. xvii. 4: Rom. iv. 17, 18; Gal. iii. 8), which was never fulfilled until after the expansion of the Church in the New Testament dispensation. And Paul says that the Jewish Church, instead of being abrogated, remains the same through all change—the Jewish branches being cut off, the Gentile branches being grafted in, and hereafter the Jews are to be restored, not to a new Church, but “into their own olive tree.” Rom. xi. 18–24. See also Eph. ii. 11–22.

(4.) Infants were members of the Church under the Old Testament from the beginning, being circumcised upon the faith of their parents. Now as the Church is the same Church; as the conditions of membership were the same then as now; as circumcision signified and bound to precisely what baptism does; and since baptism has taken precisely the place of circumcision, it follows that the church membership of the children of professors should be recognized now as it was then, and that they should be baptized. The only ground upon which this conclusion could be obviated would be that Christ in the gospel explicitly turns them out of their ancient birth-right in the Church.

(5.) On the contrary, Christ and his apostles uniformly, without exception, speak of and treat children on the assumption that they remain in the same church relation they have always occupied. Christ, speaking to Jewish apostles, who had all their lives never heard of any other than the old Pædobaptist Church, into which they had been themselves born and circumcised (and their infant circumcision was the only baptism they ever received), never once warns them that he had changed this relation. On the contrary, he says, “Of such is the kingdom of heaven” (i. e., new dispensation of the old Church). Matt. xix. 14; Luke xviii. 16. He commissioned Peter to feed the lambs as well as the sheep of the flock (John xxi. 15–17), and all the apostles to disciple “all nations,” by first baptizing and then teaching them. Matt. xxviii. 18, 19. If only one of the parents is a Christian, the children are said to be “holy,” or “saints,” which is a common designation of church members in the New Testament. 1 Cor. vii. 14. In the old Jewish Church every proselyte from the heathen brought his children into the Church with him. So the Jewish apostles write the brief history of their missionary labors precisely as all modern pædobaptist missionaries write theirs, and as no Baptist missionary ever wrote from the first rise of their denomination. There are only eleven cases of baptism recorded in the Acts and the Epistles. In the case of two of these, Paul and the Ethiopian eunuch, there were no children to be baptized. Five of the cases were large crowds. After Stephanas was baptized with the crowd among “the many Corinthians,” Paul baptized his household. Also were the households of Lydia, of the jailer, of Crispus, and probably of Cornelius, baptized. Thus in every case in which the household existed it was baptized. The faith of the head of the household is mentioned, but not that of the household itself, except in one case, and that as a general fact. The apostles also address children as members of the Church. Compare Eph. i. 1 with Eph. vi. 1–3, and Col. i. 1, 2 with Col. iii. 20.

(6.) This has been the belief and practice of a vast majority of God’s people from the first. The early Church, in unbroken continuity from the days of the apostles, testify to their custom on this subject. The Greek and Roman, and all branches of the Lutheran and Reformed churches, agree in this fundamental point. The Baptist denomination, which opposes the whole Christian world in this matter, is a very modern party, dating from the Anabaptists of Germany, A. D. 1637.

Our Standards teach that precisely the same requirements are made the condition on the part of the parent of having his child baptized that are made the condition of approach to the Lord’s table. S. Cat., Q. 95: “Infants of such as are members of the visible Church are to be baptized.” This is explained, L. Cat., Q. 166: infants “of parents, one or both of them professing faith in Christ;” and Conf. Faith, ch. xxviii., § 4: “infants of one or both believing parents.” In the Directory for Worship, ch. vii., the minister is to require of the parents, among other things, “that they pray with and for (the child); that they set an example of piety and godliness before it, and endeavour by all means of God’s appointment to bring up their child in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.” The General Assembly in 1794, in answer to an overture on the subject, declared that the above passage in the Directory is to be understood as bringing the parent under an express engagement to do as there required by the minister.1

Some have supposed, since the church-membership of the child follows from that of the parent, that every person who was himself introduced into the Church by baptism in infancy has an indefeasible right to have his children baptized, whether he professes personal faith in Christ or not. But this is manifestly absurd—(a.) Because all members of the Church have not a right to all privileges of church-membership. Thus baptized members have no right to come to the communion until they make a profession of personal faith. Until they do this they are like citizens under age, with their rights held in suspension, as a just punishment for their refusal to believe. These suspended rights are those of communing and having their children baptized. (b.) A person destitute of personal faith can only commit perjury and sacrilege by making the solemn professions and taking the obligations involved in the baptismal covenant. It is a sin for them to do it, and a sin for the minister to help them to do it.

1 Baird’s Digest, p. 81.