Paragraphs 3.1–3.2
Chapter III. Of God’s Eternal Decree
These Sections affirm the following propositions:
1st. God has had from eternity an unchangeable plan with reference to his creation.
2d. This plan comprehends and determines all things and events of every kind that come to pass.
3d. This all-comprehensive purpose is not, as a whole nor in any of its constituent elements, conditional. It in no respect depends upon his foresight of events not embraced in and determined by his purpose. It is an absolutely sovereign purpose, depending only on “the wise and holy counsel of his own will.”
4th. This purpose is, in relation to all the objects embraced within it, certainly efficacious.
5th. It is in all things consistent with his own most wise, benevolent and holy nature.
6th. It is in all things perfectly consistent with the nature and mode of action of the creatures severally embraced within it.
1st. God has had from eternity an unchangeable plan with reference to his creatures.
As an infinitely intelligent Creator and providential Ruler, God must have had a definite purpose with reference to the being and destination of all that he has created, comprehending in one all-perfect system his chief end therein, and all subordinate ends and means in reference to that chief end. And since he is an eternal and unchangeable being, his plan must have existed in all its elements, perfect and unchangeable, from eternity. Since he is an infinite, eternal, unchangeable and absolutely wise, powerful and sovereign Person, his purposes must partake of the essential attributes of his own being. And since God’s intelligence is absolutely perfect and his plan is eternal, since his ultimate end is revealed to be the single one of his own glory, and the whole work of creation and providence is observed to form one system, it follows that his plan is also single—one all-comprehensive intention, providing for all the means and conditions as well as the ends selected.
2d. The plan of God comprehends and determines all things and events of every kind that come to pass.
(1.) This is rendered certain from the fact that all God’s works of creation and providence constitute one system. No event is isolated, either in the physical or moral world, either in heaven or on earth. All of God’s supernatural revelations and every advance of human science conspire to make this truth conspicuously luminous. Hence the original intention which determines one event must also determine every other event related to it as cause, condition or consequent, direct and indirect, immediate and remote. Hence, the plan which determines general ends must also determine even the minutest element comprehended in the system of which those ends are parts. The free actions of free agents constitute an eminently important and effective element in the system of things. If the plan of God did not determine events of this class, he could make nothing certain, and his government of the world would be made contingent and dependent, and all his purposes fallible and mutable.
(2.) The Scriptures expressly declare this truth.
(a.) Of the whole system in general. He “worketh all things after the counsel of his own will.” Eph. i. 11.
(b.) Of fortuitous events. Prov. xvi. 33; Matt. x. 29, 30.
(c.) Of the free actions of men. “The king’s heart is in the hands of the Lord; as rivers of water, he turneth it whithersoever he will.” Prov. xxi. 1. “We are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.” Eph. ii. 10. “It is God that worketh in us to will and to do of his good pleasure.” Phil. ii. 13.
(d.) Of the sinful actions of men. “Him, being delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God, ye have taken and by wicked hands have crucified and slain.” Acts ii. 23. “For of a truth against thy holy child Jesus, whom thou hast anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles and the people of Israel, were gathered together, for to do whatsoever thy hand and thy counsel determined before to be done.” Acts iv. 27, 28. Compare Gen. xxxvii. 28 with Gen. xlv. 7, 8; Isa. x. 5.
It must be remembered, however, that the purpose of God with respect to the sinful acts of men and wicked angels is in no degree to cause the evil, nor to approve it, but only to permit the wicked agent to perform it, and then to overrule it for his own most wise and holy ends. The same infinitely perfect and self-consistent decree ordains the moral law which forbids and punishes all sin, and at the same time permits its occurrence, limiting and determining the precise channel to which it shall be confined, the precise end to which it shall be directed, and overruling its consequences for good. “But as for you, ye thought evil against me; but God meant it unto good, to bring to pass as it is this day, to save much people alive.” Gen. l. 20.
3d. This all-comprehensive purpose is not, as a whole nor in any of its constituent elements, conditional. It in no respect depends upon his foresight of events not embraced in and determined by his purpose. It is absolutely sovereign, depending only on the “wise and holy counsel of his own will.”
A very obvious distinction must always be kept in mind between an event being conditioned on other events, and the decree of God with reference to that event being conditioned. Calvinists believe, as all men must, that all events in the system of things depend upon their causes, and are suspended on conditions. That is, if a man does not sow seed, he will not reap; if he does sow, and all the favorable climatic influences are present, he will reap. If a man believes, he shall be saved; if he does not believe, he will not be saved. But the all-comprehensive purpose of God embraces and determines the cause and the conditions, as well as the event suspended upon them. The decree, instead of altering, determines the nature of events, and their mutual relations. It makes free actions free in relation to their agents, and contingent events contingent in relation to their conditions, while, at the same time, it makes the entire system of events, and every element embraced in it, certainly future. An absolute decree is one which, while it may determine many conditional events by determining their conditions, is itself suspended on no condition. A conditional decree is one which determines that a certain event shall happen on condition that some other undecreed event happens, upon which undecreed event the decree itself, as well as the event decreed, is suspended.
The Confession in this Section teaches that all the decrees of God are unconditional.
All who believe in a divine government agree with Calvinists that the decrees of God relating to events produced by necessary causes are unconditional. The only debate relates to those decrees which are concerned with the free actions of men and of angels. The Socinians and Rationalists maintain that God cannot certainly foresee free actions, because from their very nature they are uncertain until they are performed. Arminians admit that he certainly foresees them, but deny that he determines them. Calvinists affirm that he foresees them to be certainly future because he has determined them to be so.
The truth of the Calvinistic view is proved—(1.) From the fact that, as shown above, the decrees of God determine all classes of events. If every event that comes to pass is foreordained, it is evident that there is nothing left undetermined upon which the decree can be conditioned.
(2.) Because the decrees of God are sovereign. This is evident, (a) because God is the eternal and absolute Creator of all things. All creatures exist, and are what they are, and possess the properties peculiar to them, and act under the very conditions in which they act, because of God’s plan. (b.) It is directly affirmed in Scripture. Dan. iv. 35; Isa. xl. 13, 14; Rom. ix. 15–18; Eph. i. 5.
(3.) God’s decree includes and determines the means and conditions upon which events depend, as well as the events themselves: “According as he has chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy.” Eph. i. 4. “By grace ye are saved through faith, and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God.” Eph. ii. 8. “God has from the beginning chosen you to salvation through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth.” 2 Thess. ii. 13. In the case of Paul’s shipwreck, God first promised Paul absolutely that not a life should be lost. Acts xxvii. 24. But Paul said, verse 31: “Except these men abide in the ship, ye cannot be saved.”
(4.) The Scriptures declare that the salvation of individuals is conditional upon the personal act of faith, and at the same time that the decree of God with regard to the salvation of individuals rests solely upon “the counsel of his own will,” “his own good pleasure.” “For the children being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, that the purpose of God according to election might stand, not of works, but of him that calleth, etc.” Rom. ix. 11. “Having predestinated us according to the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will.” Eph. i. 11; i. 5; Matt. xi. 25, 26.
4th. The purpose of God is, with reference to all the objects embraced within it, certainly efficacious.
The decree of God is merely a purpose which he executes in his works of creation and providence. When it is said that all the decrees of God are certainly efficacious, it is not meant that they are the proximate causes of events, but that they render, under the subsequent economy of creation and providence, every event embraced in them absolutely certain. This is evident—(1) From the nature of God as an infinitely wise and powerful person and absolute sovereign.
(2.) From the fact that the decrees relate to all events without exception, and are sovereign and unconditional.
(3.) The Scriptures declare, with reference to such events, that there is a needs-be that they should happen as it was determined. Matt. xvi. 21; Luke xxiv. 44; xxii. 22.
5th. This purpose must in all things be perfectly consistent with his own most wise, benevolent and holy nature.
This is a self-evident truth from the nature of God as an eternal, absolutely perfect and unchangeable being. His decrees must be absolutely perfect in wisdom and righteousness.
The problem of the permission of sin is to us insoluble, because unexplained. The fact is certain, the reason beyond discovery. If God be infinitely wise and powerful, he might have prevented it. It is evident that it is consistent with absolute righteousness to permit it and to overrule it. The Arminian admits that God foresaw that sin and misery would certainly eventuate upon the conditions of creation he established. He is therefore as unable as the Calvinist is to explain why God, notwithstanding that certain knowledge, did not change those conditions.
It remains, however, certain (1) that God is not the cause of sin, (a) because he is absolutely holy; (b) because sin is in its essence ἀνομία (violation of God’s will); (c) because man as a free agent is the responsible cause of his own actions: (2) that God has permitted sin for the purpose of overruling it in the interests of righteousness and benevolence, the highest glory of God and excellence of the moral creation.
6th. The purpose of God is in all things perfectly consistent with the nature and the mode of action of the creatures severally embraced within it.
This is certain, (1) because the one eternal, self-consistent, all-comprehensive purpose of God at the same time determines the nature of the agent, his proper mode of action and each action that shall eventuate. As God’s purpose cannot be inconsistent with itself, the element of it determining the nature of the agent cannot be inconsistent with the element of it determining any particular action of the agent.
(2.) Because the decrees of God are not the proximate causes of events; they only make a given event certainly future. It provides that free agents shall be free agents, and free actions free actions, and that a given free agent shall exist, and that he shall freely perform a certain free action under certain conditions.
Now, that a given free action is certainly future, is obviously not inconsistent with the perfect freedom of the agent in that act: (1.) Because all admit that God certainly foreknows the free actions of free agents, and if so, they must be certainly future, although free. (2.) God’s actions are certainly holy, though free, and the same is true of all glorified spirits in heaven. (3.) The actions of the devil, and finally reprobate men and angels, will for ever be certainly wicked, yet free and responsible.