Paragraphs 11.1–11.2
Chapter XI. Of Justification
These Sections teach the following propositions:
1st. All those and only those whom God has effectually called he also freely justifies.
2d. This justification is a purely judicial act of God as Judge, whereby he pardons all the sins of a believer, and accounts, accepts and treats him as a person righteous in the eye of the divine law.
3d. That this justifying act proceeds upon the imputation or crediting to the believer by God of the righteousness of his great Representative and Surety, Jesus Christ.
4th. That the essential and sole condition upon which this righteousness of Christ is imputed to the believer is, that he exercises faith in or on Christ as his righteousness.
5th. That this faith is itself a gracious gift of God.
6th. That no other grace, neither love nor hope nor obedience, sustains the same relation to justification that faith does as its essential condition or instrument; yet this faith is never alone in the justified person, but is always, when genuine, accompanied with all other Christian graces, all of which have their root in faith.
1st. That God justifies all those and only those whom he has effectually called or regenerated by his grace is proved—(1.) From the express declarations of Scripture: “Whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified.” (2.) From the fact that effectual calling and justification are both necessary in order to salvation, and are both essential steps in the execution by God of his own immutable and infallibly efficacious decree of election. (3.) From the fact that only those who truly believe are justified, and only those who are regenerate can truly believe.
2d. As to its nature, this justification is a purely judicial act of God as Judge, whereby he pardons all the sins of a believer, and accounts, accepts and treats him as a person righteous in the eye of the divine law. This includes two subordinate propositions:
(1.) Justification is a judicial act of God, whereby he declares us to be conformed to the demands of the law as the condition of our life; it is not an act of gracious power, making us holy or conformed to the law as a standard of moral character. The Romanists use the term justification in a vague and general sense, as including at once the forgiveness of sins and the infusion of grace. Socinians, and those who teach the moral-influence theory of the atonement, regard justification as meaning the same as sanctification; that is, the making a man personally holy. The true sense of justification stated above is, when taken in its connection with faith, the grand central principle of the Reformation, brought out and triumphantly vindicated by Luther. That it is true is proved (a) from the universal meaning of the English word to justify, and of the equivalent Greek word used in the New Testament. They both are alike always used to express an act declaring a man to be square with the demands of law, never to express an act making him holy. Gal. ii. 16; iii. 11.
(b.) In Scripture, justification is always set forth as the opposite of condemnation. The opposite of “to sanctify” is “to pollute,” but the opposite of “to justify” is “to condemn.” Rom. viii. 30–34; John iii. 18.
(c.) The true sense of the phrase “to justify” is clearly proved by the terms used in Scripture as equivalent to it. For example: “To impute righteousness without works;” “To forgive iniquities;” “To cover sins.” Rom. iv. 6–8. “Not to impute transgression unto them.” 2 Cor. v. 19. “Not to bring into condemnation.” John v. 24.
(d.) In many passages it would produce the most obvious nonsense to substitute sanctification (the making holy) for justification (the declaring legally just); as, for instance: “For by the deeds of the law shall no flesh be sanctified;” or, “Christ is become of no effect unto you, whosoever of you are sanctified by the law; ye are fallen from grace.” Gal. ii. 16; v. 4.
(e.) Justification and sanctification are set forth in Scripture as distinct graces, inseparable, alike necessary, yet distinct in their nature, grounds and ends. 1 Cor. vi. 11.
(2.) Justification is not mere pardon; it includes pardon of sin, and in addition the declaration that all the claims of law are satisfied with respect to the person justified, and that consequently he has a right to all the immunities and rewards which in the covenant of life are suspended upon perfect conformity to the demands of law.
Pardon (a) relaxes the claims of law, or waives their exaction in a given case. (b.) It is an act of a sovereign in the exercise of pure prerogative. (c.) It is free, resting upon considerations of mercy or of public policy. (d.) It simply remits the penalty of sin; it secures neither honours nor rewards.
On the other hand, justification (a) is the act of a judge, not a sovereign. (b.) It rests purely upon the state of the law and of the facts, and is impossible where there is not a perfect righteousness. (c.) It pronounces the law not relaxed, but fulfilled in its strictest sense. (d.) It declares the person justified to be justly entitled to all the honours and advantages, suspended upon perfect conformity to all the demands of law.
The truth of this proposition is proved (a) from the uniform and obvious meaning of the words “to justify.” No one ever confounds the justification of a person with his pardon. (b.) As we saw under Chapter viii., § 5, “The Lord Jesus, by his perfect obedience and sacrifice of himself, . . . hath fully satisfied the justice of the Father, and purchased not only reconciliation, but an everlasting inheritance in the kingdom of heaven for all those whom the Father hath given unto him.” Justification, therefore, rests upon this “full satisfaction of divine justice.” It is a judicial declaration that the law is satisfied—not a sovereign waiving of the penalty.
(c.) The Scriptures declare that our justification proceeds upon the ground of a perfect righteousness. Christ “is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth.” Rom. x. 3–6; 1 Cor. i. 30. The essence of pardon is that a man is forgiven without righteousness. The essence of justification is that a man is pronounced to be possessed of righteousness, which satisfies the law. We are “made the righteousness of God in him.” 2 Cor. v. 21. Justification is paraphrased as “not imputing sin;” as “imputing righteousness without works.” Rom. iv. 6–8.
(d.) The effects of justification are much more than those of pardon. The justified have “peace with God,” “assurance of salvation,” Rom. v. 1–10; “inheritance among them that are sanctified,” Acts xxvi. 18.
3d. Justification proceeds upon the imputation or crediting to the believer by God of the righteousness of his great Representative and Surety, Jesus Christ. L. Cat., Q. 70: “Justification is an act of God’s free grace unto sinners, wherein he pardoneth all their sin, accepteth and accounteth their persons righteous in his sight; not for anything wrought in them or done by them, but only for the perfect obedience and full satisfaction of Christ, by God imputed to them, and received by faith alone.” Compare also L. Cat., Q. 77, and S. Cat., Q. 33.
Arminians hold that for Christ’s sake the demands of the law are graciously lowered, and faith and evangelical obedience accepted in the place of perfect obedience as the ground of justification. Our Standards and all the Reformed and Lutheran Confessions teach that the true ground of justification is the perfect righteousness (active and passive) of Christ, imputed to the believer and received by faith alone. S. Cat., Q. 33. This is proved—
(1.) Because the Scriptures insist everywhere that we are not justified by works. This is affirmed of works in general—of all kinds of works, natural or gracious, without distinction. Rom. iv. 4; xi. 6.
(2.) Because the Scriptures declare that good works, of whatever kind, instead of being the ground of justification, are possible only as its consequences: “For sin shall not have dominion over you, for ye are not under the law, but under grace;” “But now we are delivered from the law, that being dead wherein we were held; that we should serve in newness of the Spirit, and not in oldness of the letter.” Rom. vi. 14; vii. 6.
(3.) Because the Scriptures declare that the obedience and suffering—i. e., perfect righteousness or fulfilment of the law—by Christ, our Representative, is the true ground of justification: “Therefore, as by the offence of one judgment came upon all men to condemnation, even so by the righteousness of one the free gift came upon all men unto justification of life. For as by one man’s disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.” Rom. v. 18, 19; x. 4; 1 Cor. i. 30; 2 Cor. v. 21; Phil. iii. 9.
(4.) Because the Scriptures affirm that this righteousness is imputed to the believer in the act of justification. The phrase to impute sin or righteousness in its scriptural usage signifies simply to set to one’s account, to lay to one’s charge or credit as the ground of judicial process. Our sins are said to have been laid upon Christ (Isa. liii. 6, 12; Gal. iii. 13; Heb. ix. 28; 1 Pet. ii. 24), because their guilt was so charged to his account that they were justly punished in him. In like manner Christ’s righteousness is imputed or its rewardableness is so credited to the believer that all the covenanted honours and rewards of a perfect righteousness henceforth rightly belong to him. Rom. iv. 4–8; 2 Cor. v. 19–21. For the usage of the Hebrew and Greek equivalents of “imputation,” see Gen. xxxi. 15; Lev. vii. 18; Num. xviii. 27–30; Mark xv. 28; Luke xxii. 37; Rom. ii. 26; iv. 3–9; 2 Cor. v. 19.
This doctrine of our Standards is that of the whole Protestant body of the Reformed and Lutheran Churches.
Calvin says in his Institutes, B. 3, chap. xi., § 2: “A man will be justified by faith when, excluded from the righteousness of works, he by faith lays hold of the righteousness of Christ, and, clothed in it, appears in the sight of God, not as a sinner, but as righteous.”
The Heidelberg Cat., Q. 60: “How art thou justified in the sight of God? Only by a true faith in Jesus Christ; so that, though my conscience accuse me that I have grossly transgressed all the commandments of God, and kept none of them, and am still inclined to all evil, notwithstanding, God, without any merit of mine, but only of mere grace, grants and imputes to me, the perfect satisfaction, righteousness and holiness of Christ.” . . . .
Lutheran Form. of Concord: “That righteousness which before God is of mere grace imputed to faith, or to the believer, is the obedience, suffering and resurrection of Christ, by which he for our sakes satisfied the law and expiated our sins. . . . . On which account his obedience . . . . is imputed to us; so that God, on account of that whole obedience, . . . . remits our sins, reputes us as good and just, and gives us eternal salvation.”
4th. That the essential and sole condition upon which this gracious imputation of the righteousness of Christ to the believer proceeds is that he exercise faith in or on Christ as his righteousness or ground of acceptance and justification. Faith is here called the “condition” of justification, because it is an essential requisite, and necessary instrument whereby the soul, always treated as a free agent, appropriates the righteousness of Christ, which is the legal ground of justification.
That faith in or on Christ, and no other grace, is always represented in Scripture as the necessary instrument or means of justification, is proved. Gal. ii. 16; Rom. iv. 9; Acts xvi. 31.
That faith is the instrument whereby the soul apprehends the true ground of justification in the righteousness of Christ, and is not itself, as Arminians pretend, that ground, is proved—
(1.) Because, as above shown, the vicarious obedience and suffering of Christ is that ground.
(2.) Because faith is “a work,” and Paul asserts that justification on the ground of works is impossible.
(3.) Because faith in or on Christ evidently rests upon that which is without itself, and from its very nature is incapable of laying the foundation for a legal justification.
(4.) Because the Scriptures constantly affirm that we are justified “through” or by means of faith, but never on account of or for the sake of faith. Rom. v. 1; Gal. ii. 16.
5th. This faith itself is not our own, but a gracious gift of God. Eph. ii. 7, 8; Acts x. 44.
6th. While it is faith alone, unassociated with any other grace, which is the sole instrument of justification, yet it is never alone in the justified person, but when genuine is always accompanied with all other Christian graces. To our doctrine of justification the famous passage in James ii. 14 is often objected. But Paul and James are speaking of different things. Paul teaches that faith alone justifies. He is arguing against Pharisees and legalists. James teaches that a faith which is alone—that is, a dead faith—will not justify. He is arguing against nominal Christians who would hold the truth in unrighteousness. Paul uses the word “justify” in the sense of God’s justification of the sinner, to which faith and not works is prerequisite. James uses the word to justify in the sense of prove true, or real, in which sense faith is justified or proved genuine by works. Consequently orthodox theologians have always acknowledged that while faith alone justifies, a faith which is alone, or unassociated with other graces and fruitless in good works, will not justify. “Works,” says Luther, “are not taken into consideration when the question respects justification. But true faith will no more fail to produce them than the sun can cease to give light.”