A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraphs 1.9–1.10

Chapter I. Of the Holy Scripture

These sections teach:

1st. That the infallible and only true “rule” for the interpretation of Scripture is Scripture itself. 2d. That the Scriptures are the supreme “judge” in all controversies concerning religion.

The authority of the Scriptures as the ultimate rule of faith rests alone in the fact that they are the word of God. Since all these writings are one revelation, and the only revelation of his will concerning religion given by God to men, it follows: 1st. That they are complete as a revelation in themselves, and are not to be supplemented or explained by light drawn from any other source. 2d. That the different sections of this revelation mutually supplement and explain one another. The Holy Spirit who inspired the Scriptures is the only adequate expounder of his own words, and he is promised to all the children of God as a Spirit of light and truth. In dependance upon his guidance, Christians are of course to study the Scriptures, using all the helps of true learning to ascertain their meaning; but this meaning is to be sought in the light of the Scriptures themselves taken as a whole, and not in the light either of tradition or of philosophy.

“A rule is a standard of judgment; a judge is the expounder and applier of that rule to the decision of particular cases.”

The Romish doctrine is, that the Papal Church is the infallible teacher of men in religion; that, consequently, the Church authoritatively determines, (1) what is Scripture; (2) what is tradition; (3) what is the true sense of Scripture and of tradition; and (4) what is the true application of that rule to every particular question of faith or practice.

The Protestant doctrine is, 1st. That the Scriptures are the only rule of faith and practice; 2d. (a) negatively, that there is no body of men qualified or authorized to interpret the Scriptures or to apply their teachings to the decision of particular questions in a sense binding upon their fellow-Christians; (b) positively, that the Scriptures are the only authoritative voice in the Church, which is to be interpreted and applied by every individual for himself, with the assistance, though not by the authority, of his fellow-Christians. Creeds and confessions, as to form, bind those only who voluntarily profess them; and as to matter, they bind only so far as they affirm truly what the Bible teaches, and because the Bible does so teach.

This must be true, 1st. Because the Scriptures, which profess to teach us the way of salvation, refer us to no standard or judge in matters of religion beyond or above themselves, and because no body of men since the apostles have ever existed with the qualifications or with the authority to act in the office of judge for their fellows.

2d. Because, as we have seen, the Scriptures are themselves complete and perspicuous.

3d. Because all Christians are commanded to search the Scriptures, and to judge both doctrines and professed teachers themselves. John v. 39; 1 John ii. 20, 27; iv. 1, 2; Acts xvii. 11; Gal. i. 8; 1 Thess. v. 21.

4th. Because all Christians are promised the Holy Spirit to guide them in the understanding and practical use of the truth. Rom. viii. 9; 1 John ii. 20, 27.