A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraph 32.1

Chapter XXXII. Of the State of Men after Death, and of the Resurrection of the Dead

This Section teaches—

1st. That man consists of two distinct elements, a soul and a body, and that death consists in their temporary separation.

2d. That while the body is resolved into its constituent chemical elements, the soul of the believer is (a) immediately made perfect in holiness, (b) during all the intermediate state from death until the resurrection, continues conscious, active and happy, and (c) is in the presence of Christ, who, after his ascension, has sat down at the right hand of God.

3d. That the souls of the wicked also continue, during this intermediate state, conscious and active, but in a state of penal torment, reserved to the judgment of the great day.

4th. These conditions, though not final, are irreversible—i. e., none of those with Christ will be ever lost, and none of those in torment will be ever saved.

5th. The Scriptures afford no ground whatever for the Romish doctrine that there are other places or conditions occupied by deceased men than the two above mentioned.

1st. The duality of human nature, as consisting of two separable elements—a soul and a body—having distinct and independent attributes and subsistence, is taken for granted and constantly implied in the language of Scripture. Thus God made the body out of the dust of the earth and breathed into it the breath of life, and so man became a living soul. Gen. ii. 7. Christ bids us not to “fear them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul.” Matt. x. 28. And death is defined in Eccles. xii. 7, a dissolution of the personal union of these two elements; for “then shall the dust return to the earth as it was, and the spirit shall return unto God who gave it.” In like manner Paul (2 Cor. v. 8; Phil. i. 22–24) defines it as a departing, a being with Christ, a ceasing to abide in the flesh, a being absent from the body on the part of the conscious personal soul.

2d. We know that when the soul leaves it the body is resolved into its original chemical elements, which are gradually incorporated with the shifting currents of matter on the surface of the earth. The Scriptures teach us, however, that, in spite of this flux of their material constituents, the real identity of our bodies is preserved, and that, as members of Christ, all that is essential to them will be ultimately preserved and brought to a glorious resurrection.

As to the condition and location of the souls of men during the interval which elapses between the death of each individual and the general and simultaneous resurrection of the bodies of all, what the Scriptures teach us may be summed up under the following heads:

(1.) The souls of both believers and the reprobate continue after death conscious and active, although they remain until the resurrection separate from their bodies.

(2.) The souls of believers are at their death made perfect in holiness.

(3.) The souls of believers, thus perfected, are immediately introduced into the presence of Christ and continue to enjoy bright revelations of God and the society of the holy angels.

(4.) The souls of the reprobate are at once introduced into the place provided for the devil and his angels, and continue in unutterable misery.

(5.) This state of both classes admits of no exchange or transfer, but their present condition is the commencement of an inevitable progression in opposite directions. Nevertheless, it is intermediate in the sense (a) that the persons of men continue incomplete while their souls and bodies are separate. (b.) That neither the redemption of the saved nor the perdition of the lost has yet reached its final stage. (c.) That possibly, in the case of the last, and very probably in the case of the redeemed, the localities in which they are at present are not the same as those in which they are to dwell permanently after the final award.

(6.) As to the location of the place in which the souls of the reprobate suffer, the Scriptures give us no clue. In Jude, verse 7, it is said, “The angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgment of the great day.” In Matt. xxv. 41, the Judge at the last day says to those “on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.” The rich man (Luke xvi. 23) lifted up his eyes in hell, being in torment, while his brethren were still alive on earth. But where these places are situated, and whether the locality of torment now is identical with the locality of torment after the judgment, no man can tell, because God has not revealed it. Of course, the terms “up” or “down,” “under” or “above,” applied to such a subject, must be simply metaphorical, and cannot indicate absolute direction when addressed promiscuously to the inhabitants of a revolving and rotating sphere.

(7.) As to the location of the place where the redeemed are now gathered, absolutely nothing is revealed, except that it is wherever the glorified humanity of Christ is. They are with him, and behold his glory. 2 Cor. v. 1–8. See, also, all the scenes opened in the Apocalypse. And Christ at his ascension, sat down at “the right hand of God,” “the right hand of the Majesty on high.” Mark xvi. 19; Rom. viii. 34; Heb. i. 3; x. 12, etc. This must be a locality, because, the humanity of Christ being finite, his presence marks a definite place; yet the phrase “right hand of God” evidently marks rather the condition of honour and power to which Christ is raised as mediatorial King. As to the location of the place in which Christ and his glorified spouse will hold their central home throughout eternity, a strong probability is raised that it will be our present earth, first burned with fire and then gloriously replenished. See Rom. viii. 19–23; 2 Pet. iii. 5–13; Rev. xxi. 1.

The proof of the main propositions above stated—viz.: that the intermediate state of souls is one of conscious activity, the redeemed being perfectly holy and happy with Christ, and the reprobate being with the devil and his angels in torment, and that these conditions are for ever irreversible—can be better presented collectively than distributively. It is as follows: The reappearance of Samuel in a conscious state, in the use of all his faculties, at the call of Saul and the witch of Endor (1 Sam. xxviii. 7–20); the appearance of Moses and Elias at the transfiguration of Christ on the mount (Matt. xvii. 3); Christ’s address to the thief on the cross—“To-day thou shalt be with me in paradise” (Luke xxiii. 43); the parable of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke xvi. 23, 24): Lazarus is conscious and active in Abraham’s bosom; the rich man is in conscious torment in hell (Hades), while his brethren are still living in the flesh. Of dying Stephen it is declared (Acts vii. 55–59) that, being full of the Holy Ghost, he saw the heavens opened, and Jesus Christ sitting at the right hand of God, and so seeing he cried, “Lord Jesus, receive my spirit! and so died.”

In 2 Cor. v. 1–8, Paul declares that to be at home in the body is to be absent from the Lord; and to be absent from the body is to the believer to be present with the Lord; and hence he says (in Phil. i. 21–24) that for him to die is gain, and that he was in “a strait betwixt two; having a desire to depart and be with Christ which is far better; nevertheless to abide in the flesh is more needful for you.” In 1 Thess. v. 10, Paul declares that the sleep of death is “a living together with Christ.” In Eph. iii. 15, the Church is declared to be one whole family, of which at present part is in heaven and part on earth. In Heb. vi. 12–20, it is declared that after Abraham (and other ancient saints) had patiently endured, “he obtained the promises;” which promises, we know, were in their true meaning spiritual and heavenly. In Acts i. 25, Judas is said to have gone to his own place. In Jude 6, 7, the lost angels are said to be reserved in everlasting chains, under darkness, unto the judgment of the last day, suffering the vengeance of eternal fire. In Heb. vii. 23, the spirits of the just are represented as made perfect and happy with the angels in heaven. In Rev. vi. 9–11, the souls of the martyrs are represented as under the altar in heaven, praying for the punishment of their former persecutors on earth, which of course must be before the resurrection. In Rev. v. 9; vii. 9; xiv. 1, 3, the souls of believers are represented as being now with Christ and the holy angels.

3d. Our Standards declare that there is no foundation whatever, in Scripture, for the Romish doctrine as to the intermediate state of deceased men. The Papists hold that hades or the under world embraces several distinct regions, to which different classes of human souls are destined: (1.) The souls of unbaptized infants go to the “Limbus Infantum,” where they remain without suffering, and yet without the vision of God. (2.) Old Testament believers were gathered in the “Limbus Patrum,” where, without suffering and yet without the vision of God, they remained the “spirits in prison” until Christ, during the three days he continued under the power of death, came and released them. 1 Pet. iii. 19, 20. (3.) All unbaptized adults, and those who have subsequently lost the grace of baptism, and die unreconciled to the Church, go immediately to the permanent hell. (4.) All Christians who have attained a state of Christian perfection go immediately to heaven. (5.) The great mass of partially-sanctified Christians, dying in communion with the Church, still cumbered with imperfections, go to purgatory.1

Concerning purgatory, the Council of Trent teaches—(a.) That there is a purifying fire through which imperfect Christians must pass. (b.) That souls in purgatory may be benefited by the prayers and masses offered in their behalf on earth.2

This doctrine is false, because (1) it is nowhere taught in Scripture. (2.) It is opposed to the teaching of Scripture as to the intermediate state, as above shown. (3.) It rests upon Antichristian principles as to the efficacy of the atonement of Christ, as to the sin-expiating and soul-purifying efficacy of temporary suffering, as to the sacrifice of the mass, and as to prayers for the dead, etc.

1 Cat. Rom., Pt. I., ch. vi.

2 Council of Trent, sess. xxv.