Paragraph 6.1
Chapter VI. Of the Fall of Man, of Sin, and of the Punishment Thereof
God having brought the souls of Adam and Eve into being by immediate creation holy, and with sufficient knowledge as to his will, capable of obedience yet fallible, this Section proceeds to teach:
1st. That they sinned.
2d. That the particular sin they committed was their eating the forbidden fruit.
3d. That they were seduced thereto by the subtlety and temptation of Satan.
4th. That this sin was permissively embraced in the sovereign purpose of God.
5th. That in so doing God designed to order it to his own glory.
1st. Our first parents sinned.
2d. The particular sin they committed was their eating the forbidden fruit.
It appears to be God’s general plan, and one eminently wise and righteous, to introduce all the new-created subjects of moral government into a state of probation for a time, in which he makes their permanent character and destiny depend upon their own action. He creates them holy, yet capable of falling. In this state he subjects them to a moral test for a time. If they stand the test, the reward is that their moral characters are confirmed and rendered infallible, and they are introduced into an inalienable blessedness for ever. If they fail, they are judicially excluded from God’s favour and communion for ever, and hence morally and eternally dead. This certainly has been his method of dealing with new-created angels and men. In the case of mankind the specific test to which our first parents were subjected was their abstaining from eating of the fruit of a single tree. As this was a matter in itself morally indifferent, it was admirably adapted to be a test of their implicit allegiance to God of their absolute faith and submission.
The dreadful sin which they committed in eating this fruit appears from the indications afforded in the record in Genesis to have been—(1.) Unbelief. They were induced to doubt the wisdom of the divine prohibition and the certainty of the divine threatening. (2.) Disobedience. They set their will in opposition to God’s will.
In respect to the origin of sin in this world, there are two questions which men constantly ask, and which it is impossible to answer:
A. How could sinful desires or volitions originate in the soul of moral agents created holy like Adam and Eve? Men exercise choice according to their prevailing desires and affections. If these are holy, their wills are holy. And the character of their prevailing affections and desires is determined by the moral state of their souls. If their souls are holy, these are holy; if their souls are sinful, these are sinful. Christ says, “a good man, out of the good treasure of the heart, bringeth forth good things; and an evil man, out of the evil treasure, bringeth forth evil things.” “Either make the tree good, and his fruit good; or else make the tree corrupt, and his fruit corrupt.” Matt. xii. 33, 35. But Adam’s heart had been created holy; how then could his action be sinful?
All our experience conspires to make the question more difficult. The sinful souls of fallen men never can give birth to holy volitions until they are regenerated by divine grace. The holy spirits of angels and glorified men in heaven are for ever removed from all liability to sinful affections or actions. In both these cases the stream continues as the fountain.
Now, although we cannot explain precisely the origin of sin in the holy soul of Adam, it is plain that the difficulty lies only in our ignorance. (1.) We have none of us experienced the same conditions of free agency as those which give character to the case of Adam. We have always been under the bondage of corruption, except in so far as we are momentarily assisted against nature by supernatural grace. Now, in order that a volition shall be holy, it must spring from a positively holy affection or disposition, and as these are not native to our hearts, we cannot exercise holy volitions without grace. But Adam was in a state of probation, holy yet fallible. Saints and angels are holy and infallible, yet their infallibility is not essential to their natures, but is a superadded divine grace sustained by the direct power of God. While holiness must always be positive, rooting itself in divine love, it is plain that sin may originate in defect; not in positive alienation, but in want of watchfulness, in the temporary ascendency of the natural and innocent appetites of the body or constitutional tendencies of the soul over the higher powers of conscience.
The motives which appear to have led to this dreadful sin in the case of our first parents were not intrinsically sinful, but became so when dwelt upon and allowed gradually to occupy the mind and sway the will in despite of the divine prohibition. They were—(1.) Natural appetite for the attractive fruit. (2.) Natural desire for knowledge. (3.) The persuasive power of the superior mind and will of Satan. In this last fact, that, 3d, they were seduced thereto by the subtlety and temptation of Satan, much of the solution of this mystery lies. To the fall of Satan and his angels in the remote past, and under conditions of which we have no knowledge, the true origin of sin is to be referred.
B. The other element of mystery with regard to the origin of sin relates to the permission of God. This Section affirms, 4th, That this sin was permissively embraced in the eternal purpose of God.
About the facts of the case there can be no doubt. (1.) God did certainly foreknow that if such a being as Adam was put in such conditions as he was, he would sin as he sinned. Yet, in spite of this certain knowledge, God created that very being and put him in those very conditions, and having determined to overrule the sin for good, he sovereignly decreed not to intervene to prevent, and so he made it certainly future. (2.) On the other hand, God did neither cause nor approve Adam’s sin. He forbade it, and presented motives which should have deterred from it. He created Adam holy and fully capable of obedience, and with sufficient knowledge of his duty, and then left him alone to his trial. If it be asked why God, who abhors sin, and who benevolently desires the excellence and happiness of his creatures, should sovereignly determine to permit such a fountain of pollution, degradation and misery to be opened, we can only say, with profound reverence, “Even so, Father, for so it seemed good in thy sight!”
5th. That God from the beginning designed to order the sin of Adam to his own glory is included in what we have already proved in the Chapters on Creation and Providence—(a.) That God overrules the sins of his creatures for good. (b.) That the chief end of all God’s purposes and works is the manifestation of his own glory.