A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraphs 15.3–15.5

Chapter XV. Of Repentance unto Life

These Sections teach the following propositions:

1st. That repentance is not to be rested in, as any satisfaction for sin or any cause of the pardon thereof.

2d. That, nevertheless, it is of such necessity that it is inseparable from pardon, so that none who are non-repentant are pardoned.

3d. That while the least sin deserves condemnation, the same grace of Christ which bringeth repentance avails to extinguish the guilt of the greatest sin.

4th. That, as men ought to repent of their sinful disposition by nature and the general sinfulness of their lives, so they ought also to repent of every particular sin known to them.

1st. Repentance is not to be rested in as any satisfaction for sin or any cause of the pardon thereof. This directly contradicts the opinion of Socinians, the advocates of the moral-influence theory of the atonement, and Rationalists generally, to the effect that the repentance of the sinner is the only satisfaction the law requires, and hence the only condition God demands, as prerequisite to full pardon and restoration to divine favour.

It also contradicts the Romish doctrine of penance. They distinguish penance—(1.) As a virtue, which is internal, including sorrow for sin and a turning from sin unto God. (2.) As a sacrament, which is the external expression of the internal state. This sacrament consists (a) of contrition—i. e., sorrow and detestation of past sins, with a purpose of sinning no more; (b) confession or self-accusation to a priest having jurisdiction and the power of the keys; (c) satisfaction or some painful work, imposed by the priest and performed by the penitent, to satisfy divine justice for sins committed; and (d) absolution, pronounced by the priest judicially and not merely declaratively. They hold that the element of satisfaction included in this sacrament makes a real satisfaction for sin, and is an efficient cause of pardon, absolutely essential—the only means whereby the pardon of sins committed after baptism can be secured.1

That repentance is no cause whatever of the pardon of sin is proved by all that the Scriptures teach us (a) as to the justice of God, which inexorably demands the punishment of every sin; (b) as to the necessity for the satisfaction rendered to the law and justice of God by the obedience and suffering of Christ; (c) as to the fact that he has rendered a full satisfaction in behalf of all for whom he died; (d) as to the impossibility of any man’s securing justification by works of any kind; and (e) as to the fact that the believer is justified solely on the ground of the righteousness of Christ imputed to him and received by faith alone. All these points have already been discussed under their appropriate heads; and they are more than sufficient to prove (1) that pardon is secured entirely on a different basis; (2) that the external penance of the Romanist is an impertinent attempt to supplement the perfect satisfaction of Christ; and (3) that internal repentance, when genuine, is itself a gracious gift of God, without merit in itself, and of value only because it springs from the application of Christ’s grace to the soul and leads to the application by the soul to Christ’s grace.

2d. Nevertheless, repentance is of such necessity to all sinners that none may expect pardon without it. This is evident—(1) Because the giving of pardon to a non-repentant sinner would be in effect to sanction his sin, to confirm him in his sinful state, and to encourage others therein. Although Scripture and the moral sense of men teach that repentance is no adequate satisfaction for sin nor an equivalent for the penalty, they just as clearly teach that it would be inconsistent in every sense with good morals to pardon a person cherishing an unrepentant spirit. (2.) Repentance is the natural and instant sequence of the grace of regeneration. It also embraces an element of faith in Christ, and that faith is, as we have seen, the instrument of justification. He that repents believes. He that does not repent does not believe. He that does not believe is not justified. Regeneration and justification are never separated. (3.) The design of Christ’s work is to save his people from their sins. He frees them from the guilt of their sins by pardon, and he brings them clear from the power of their sins through repentance. “Him hath God exalted, . . . . to give repentance to Israel and forgiveness of sins.” Acts v. 31. (4.) Repentance, like faith, is a duty as well as a grace, and ministers are commanded to preach it as essential to forgiveness. Luke xxiv. 47; Acts xx. 21.

3d. That the least sin deserves punishment is obvious. The moral law is moral in every element, and it is of the essence of that which is moral that it is obligatory, and that its violation is deserving of reprobation. Hence “whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, is guilty of all.” James ii. 10. That there is no sin so great that it can bring condemnation upon those that truly repent is also evident, because true repentance, as we have seen, is the fruit of regeneration, and no man is regenerated who is not also justified. Besides, true repentance includes faith, and faith unites to Christ and secures the imputation of his righteousness, and the righteousness of Christ of course cancels all possible sin. Rom. viii. 1; v. 20.

4th. That men ought to repent not only in general of the corruption of their hearts and sinfulness of their lives, but also of every particular sinful action of which they are conscious and that when possible they should redress the wrong done by their actions, is a dictate alike of natural conscience and Scripture. Luke xix. 8; 1 John i. 9. No man has any right to presume that he hates sin in general unless he practically hates every sin in particular; and no man has any right to presume that he is sorry for and ready to renounce his own sins in general unless he is conscious of practically renouncing and grieving for each particular sin into which he falls.

1 Cat. Rom., Part. ii., chap. v., Qs. 12 and 13.