A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraphs 27.1–27.2

Chapter XXVII. Of the Sacraments

The word sacrament does not occur in the Scriptures. In its classical usage it designated anything which binds or brings under obligations, as a sum of money given in pledge, or an oath, and especially the oath of military allegiance.

In its ecclesiastical usage, the word while retaining its general sense of something binding as sacred, was at an early period used as the Latin equivalent of the Greek word mysterion (μυστηριον), that which is unknown until revealed, and hence any symbol, type or rite having a latent spiritual meaning. Hence the word naturally came to be applied in a general and vague sense to the Christian ordinances of baptism and the Lord’s Supper, and with them also to many other religious doctrines and ordinances.

It is plainly, therefore, impossible to determine the nature or the number of the sacraments from either the etymology or the usage of the word sacrament. We want a thorough definition of the thing, not of the name. This we can get only by taking baptism and the Lord’s Supper, which all men acknowledge to be genuine sacraments, and, by a strict examination of their origin, nature and uses, determine (a) the true character of the class of ordinances to which they belong, and (b) whether any other ordinances belong to the same class or not. In this way the definition of a sacrament given in our Standards was formed. This definition involves the following points:

1st. A sacrament is an ordinance immediately instituted by Christ. L. Cat., Q. 162, and S. Cat., Q. 92.

2d. A sacrament always consists of two elements—(a) an outward sensible sign, and (b) an inward spiritual grace thereby signified.

3d. The sign in every sacrament is sacramentally united to the grace which it signifies; and out of this union the scriptural usage has arisen of ascribing to the sign whatever is true of that which the sign signifies.

4th. The sacraments were designed to “represent, seal and apply the benefits of Christ and the new covenant to believers.” S. Cat., Q. 92.

5th. They were designed to be pledges of our fidelity to Christ, binding us to his service, and at the same time badges of our profession, visibly marking the body of professors and distinguishing them from the world.

1st. The first Section of this Chapter says that a sacrament is an ordinance “immediately instituted by God to represent Christ,” etc. This is true if the word sacrament is used in its general sense to include also the Old Testament sacraments of circumcision and the passover. But it is an important distinction of the New Testament sacraments of baptism and the Lord’s Supper that they were both immediately instituted by Christ himself. Therefore, both the Larger (Q. 162) and Shorter (Q. 92) Catechisms have it, “A sacrament is an holy ordinance instituted by Christ in his Church.” This should be remembered, because it serves to exclude most of the pretended sacraments of the Church of Rome from any right to a place in this class of Christian ordinances.

2d. Every sacrament consists of two elements—(a) an outward sensible sign, and (b) an inward spiritual grace thereby signified. In baptism the outward sensible sign is (a) water, and (b) the water applied in the name of the Triune God to the person of the subject baptized. The inward spiritual grace thereby signified is (a) primarily spiritual purification by the immediate personal power of the Holy Ghost in the soul, and (b) hence, secondarily, the indwelling of the Holy Ghost, hence the union of the baptized with Christ, hence regeneration, justification, sanctification, perseverance to the end, glorification, etc.—i. e., all the benefits of the new covenant. In the Lord’s Supper, the outward sensible signs are—(a) bread and wine, and (b) the consecration and the bread broken, and the wine poured out, distributed to, and received and eaten and drunk by, the communicants. The inward spiritual grace thereby signified is (a) primarily Christ crucified (his flesh torn and blood shed) for us, and giving himself to us to be spiritually received and assimilated as the principle of a new life, and (b) hence, secondarily, union with Christ, the indwelling of the Spirit, regeneration, justification, sanctification, etc.—i. e., all the benefits secured by the sacrificial death of Christ.

3d. “There is in every sacrament a spiritual relation or sacramental union between the sign and the thing signified.” This sacramental union between the sign and the grace which it signifies, the Romish and Lutheran churches understand to be, at least in the case of the Lord’s Supper, a literal identity. Thus when Christ took the bread and said, “This is my body,” they insist that it means that the bread is his body. All other Christians understand the phrase to mean, “This bread represents sacramentally my body.”

This sacramental union, therefore, between the sign and the thing signified is (a) symbolical and representative—the one symbolizes and so represents the other; and (b) instrumental because by divine appointment, through the right use of the sign, the grace signified is really conveyed.

The grounds of this sacramental union are—(a.) The natural fitness of the sign to symbolize the grace signified, as washing with water to symbolize spiritual purification by the Holy Ghost. (b.) The authoritative appointment of Christ that these signs rightly used shall truly represent and convey the grace they signify. (c.) The spiritual faith of the believing recipient, a gift of the Spirit of Christ, whereby in the proper use of the sign, he is enabled to discern “the Lord’s body.” 1 Cor. xi. 29.

Out of this spiritual relation, or sacramental union between the sign and the grace signified, which we have thus explained by a natural and legitimate use of language, the one is put for the other, and whatever is true of the grace signified is asserted of the sign which signifies it. Thus, to eat the bread and drink the wine in the Lord’s Supper is to eat the flesh and drink the blood of Christ; that is, to participate in the sacrificial virtue of his death. And whatever is true of baptism with the Holy Ghost is attributed to baptism with water. Ananias said to Paul, “Arise and be baptized, and wash away your sins.” Acts xxii. 16. “Christ gave himself for the Church, that he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the Word.” Eph. v. 26. “Repent and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ, for the remission of sins.” Acts ii. 38. Hence Romanists and Ritualists have inferred that the sign is inseparable from the grace signified, and that these spiritual effects are due to the outward ordinance. Hence the doctrine of baptismal regeneration. But it must be observed that the Scriptures do not assert these spiritual attributes of water baptism in itself considered, but of water baptism as the sign or emblem of baptism by the Holy Ghost. These spiritual attributes belong only to baptism by the Spirit, and they accompany the sign only when the sign is accompanied by that which it signifies. It does not follow, however, that the sign is inseparable from the grace. The grace is sovereign; and experience teaches us that it is often absent from the sign, and that the sign is least frequently honoured by the presence of the grace when it is itself most implicitly relied upon.

4th. The sacraments were designed (1) to represent the benefits of Christ and the new covenant. They are as signs or pictures of the truths they represent, and hence present those truths to the eyes and other senses of the recipients in a manner analogous to that in which they are presented to the ears in the preaching of the Word. This follows from what has just been shown as to their being outward, sensible signs, signifying inward and spiritual graces. (2.) They were designed to be “seals” of the benefits of the new covenant. The gospel is presented under the form of a covenant. Salvation and all the benefits of Christ’s redemption are offered upon the condition of faith. In the sacrament God sensibly and authoritatively pledges himself to invest us with this grace if we believe and obey. In receiving the sacrament we actively assume all the obligations implied in the gospel, and bind ourselves to fulfil them. Circumcision, Paul says, “is the seal of the righteousness of faith,” Rom. iv. 11; and baptism is declared to be the circumcision of Christ. Col. ii. 11, 12. We are said to be actually buried with Christ in baptism; i. e., united to him in his death. Jesus says, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood;” that is, This cup represents my blood, by which the new covenant was ratified; and therefore it is a visible confirmation of the covenant, since it is a visible representative of the blood. If a man was circumcised, he was a debtor to do the whole law. Gal. v. 3. As many as are baptized unto Christ have put on Christ. Gal. iii. 27.

(3.) The sacraments were designed to “apply”—i. e., actually to convey—to believers the benefits of the new covenant. If they are “seals” of the covenant, they must of course, as a legal form of investiture, actually convey the grace represented to those to whom it belongs. Thus a deed conveys an estate, or the key handed over in the presence of witnesses the possession of a house from the owner to the renter. Our Confession is explicit and emphatic on this subject. The old English word “exhibit,” there used, does not mean to show forth; but in the sense of the Latin exhibere, from which it is derived, to administer, to apply. Compare the following: “A sacrament is a holy ordinance instituted by Christ; wherein, by sensible signs, Christ and the benefits of the new covenant are represented, sealed and applied to believers.” L. Cat., Q. 92. “A sacrament is a holy ordinance instituted by Christ in his Church, to signify, seal and exhibit unto those that are within the covenant of grace the benefits of his mediation.” L. Cat., Q. 162. “The grace which is exhibited in or by the sacraments, rightly used, is not conferred by any power in them.” Conf. Faith, chap. xxvii., § 3. “The efficacy of baptism is not tied to the moment of time wherein it is administered; yet notwithstanding, by the right use of this ordinance, the grace promised is not only offered, but really exhibited and conferred by the Holy Ghost,” etc. Conf. Faith, chap. xxviii., § 6. This the Confession carefully guards in the third Section of this Chapter, showing that the sacraments have no inherent power or virtue at all, but that the right use of the sacrament is by divine appointment the occasion upon which the Holy Ghost conveys the grace to those to whom it belongs. So that this grace-conferring virtue depends upon two things: (a.) The sovereign will and power of the Holy Spirit. (b.) The lively faith of the recipient. The sacrament is a mere instrument; but it is an instrument of divine appointment.

5th. The sacraments being seals of the covenant of grace—at once pledges of God’s faithfulness to us and of our obligation to him—they of course (a) mark us as the divine property, and bind us to the performance of our duty, (b) and hence are badges of our profession, and, putting a visible difference between those who belong to the Church and the rest of the world, give visibility to the Church, and separate its members from the world.