A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraphs 31.1–31.2

Chapter XXXI. Of Synods and Councils

As we have seen in the last Chapter, all Church power is vested by Christ in the Church as a whole, not as a mob, but as an organized body. As organized, the Church consists of presbyters or bishops and the people, and the people as represented by lay or ruling elders. This necessarily gives origin to the session or parochial presbytery, consisting of the bishop or pastor and the ruling elders or representatives of the people. In this body the entire ecclesiastical power of the whole congregation is vested. It admits candidates to sealing ordinances, exercises pastoral care and discipline over the members and provides for the instruction of the flock and regulates public worship.

In the Episcopal Church this governing power vests with the rector. In the Congregational churches it is exercised immediately by the whole body of the brotherhood in person. In the Presbyterian Church it vests with pastor and people—the people, however, acting only through their permanent representatives, the ruling elders.

But the third great principle of Presbyterianism, as stated in the preceding Chapter, is that the whole Church of Christ on earth “is one in such a sense that a smaller part is subject to a larger, and a larger to the whole. It has one Lord, one faith, one baptism. The principles of government laid down in the Scriptures bind the whole Church. The terms of admission and the legitimate grounds of exclusion are everywhere the same. The same qualifications are everywhere to be demanded for admission to the sacred office, and the same grounds for deposition. Every man who is properly received as a member of a particular church becomes a member of the Church universal; every one rightfully excluded from a particular church is excluded from the whole Church; every one rightfully ordained to the ministry in one church is a minister of the universal Church, and when rightfully deposed in one he ceases to be a minister in any. Hence, while every particular church has a right to manage its own affairs and administer its own discipline, it cannot be independent and irresponsible in the exercise of that right. As its members are the members of the Church universal, and those whom it excommunicates are, according to the scriptural theory, delivered unto Satan and cut off from the communion of the saints, the acts of a particular church become the acts of the whole Church, and therefore the whole has a right to see that they are performed according to the law of Christ. Hence, on the one hand, the right of appeal, and on the other the right of review and control.”1

The principle contained in the above statement was certainly acted upon in the apostolic age, and it has been practically recognized and acted upon with more or less fidelity in all branches of the Christian Church ever since.

“A controversy having arisen in the Church at Antioch, concerning the Mosaic law, instead of settling it among themselves as an independent body, they referred the case to the apostles and elders at Jerusalem, and there it was authoritatively decided (not by the apostles alone, but ‘by the apostles and elders and the whole Church,’ Acts xv. 22)—not for that church (Antioch) only, but for all others. Paul, therefore, in his next missionary journey, as ‘he passed through the cities, delivered to them,’ it is said, ‘the decrees for to keep, which were ordained of the apostles and elders which were at Jerusalem.’ Acts xvi. 4.”2

Hence, in carrying these principles into effect, the constitution of the Presbyterian Church (see Book I. of Government), provides for the erection and operation of a regularly-graduated series of ecclesiastical councils.

(1.) Every particular congregation is governed, as we have seen, by a session or parochial presbytery, consisting of its pastor and the ruling elders as the representatives of the people. The whole governmental power of that particular church vests in that session, and all trials for the discipline of any of its members must originate there. Its decisions are final with respect to the matters subject to its jurisdiction, except when, after having been regularly carried up by appeal, they have been reversed by a superior court.

(2.) There is the classical Presbytery, which consists of all the pastors or bishops and the churches in a city or neighbourhood who can conveniently meet together and unite in the exercise of ecclesiastical government. The churches appear in the Presbytery by representatives from the sessions of particular churches, so regulated that the number of lay representatives shall exactly equal the number of pastors; and these representatives of the people in all respects exercise equal power with the pastors. All the powers of these bodies vest in them as bodies, and not in the members severally. Whatever they are competent to decide or to execute, can be done only by the members jointly while in session, and not at all by them separately or even jointly in any other capacity. Ordained ministers are not members of particular churches, but belong in the first instance to the Presbytery. The Presbytery, therefore, in the first instance, examines and decides upon the qualifications of candidates, licenses and ordains them, and in the case of the discipline of a minister the process originates in the Presbytery to which alone the pastor is directly responsible. A licentiate is in no sense or degree a minister. He is purely a layman—i. e., a private member of a particular church—taken under care of Presbytery experimentally, and as a part of his trials or tests temporarily allowed to preach before the people, that they may pass their final judgment upon his qualifications and acceptability as a candidate for the ministry.

(3.) Synods are only large Presbyteries, consisting of all the Presbyteries in full of a province.

(4.) The General Assembly of the whole Church, which, like all the other bodies, consists of an equal number of pastors and of the representatives of the people, of necessity is composed of the representatives of the constituent Presbyteries, instead of the Presbyteries themselves in full.

In virtue of the principle of appeal, any question originating in a church session, or any other subordinate court, may be carried up in succession through all the series to the General Assembly, whose decisions when once made are final.

In virtue of the principle of review and control, each church court of every grade above a church session has the right and is under obligation to review “the records of the proceedings of the judicatory next below,” and of course to judge of those proceedings, and secure their correction when wrong. And each court, including the church session, is an executive as well as a judicial body, and therefore has an inherent right of supervision and of governmental control over the entire field subject to their jurisdiction. Hence a superior judicatory, in default of the proper action of the inferior judicatory to which the case more immediately belongs, may inaugurate investigation and apply discipline immediately in the case of any person within its legitimate bounds.

1 “What is Presbyterianism?” Dr. C. Hodge.

2 Ibid.