Paragraphs 30.2–30.4
Chapter XXX. Of Church Censures
These Sections teach—
1st. As to the nature and extent of the power conferred upon the Church of admitting and excluding from the fold, and of disciplining its members.
2d. As to the ends of this discipline.
3d. As to the methods through which it should be administered.
All Church power must be exercised in an orderly manner through the officers spoken of above, freely chosen for this purpose by the brethren; and it relates—“1. To matters of doctrine. She has a right to set forth a public declaration of the truths which she believes, and which are to be acknowledged by all who enter her communion. That is, she has a right to frame creeds or confessions of faith, as her testimony for the truth and her protest against error. And as she has been commissioned to teach all nations, she has the right of selecting teachers, of judging of their fitness, of ordaining and sending them forth into the field, and of recalling and deposing them when unfaithful. 2. The Church has power to set down rules for the ordering of public worship. 3. She has power to make rules for her own government; such as every Church has in its book of discipline, constitution or canons, etc. 4. She has power to receive into fellowship, and to exclude the unworthy from her own communion.”1
This last power is commonly styled “the power of the keys;” i. e. of opening and closing the doors of the Church, of admitting or excluding from sealing ordinances. Matt. xvi. 19. In view of two unquestionable facts—(a) to forgive sin is an incommunicable attribute of God and Christ; (b) God has given to no class of men the faculty of absolutely discriminating the good from the bad—it follows that the Church power of opening and shutting, of binding and loosing, spoken of in Matt. xvi. 19 and in the second Section of this Chapter, is purely ministerial and declarative. Church censures declare simply what is, to the best of their knowledge, in the opinion of the church officers pronouncing them, the mind and will of Christ in the case. And they have direct binding effect only in so far as the relations of the person censured to the visible Church is concerned. They can have effect upon the relations of the censured to God and to Christ only in so far as they represent the will of Christ in the case, and because they do.
The ends of Church discipline are declared to be—(a.) The purity of the Church, and hence the glory and approbation of God. (b.) The recovery of the erring brother himself. (c.) The force of example to deter others from like sin. (d.) The exhibition of righteousness and fidelity to principle presented to the world without.
The better to attain all these ends, for which the discipline is intended, the church officers should—(1.) Proceed in a regular order to administer discipline, using, according to their character, first all means of moral reclamation before they proceed to absolute exclusion. The proper method of procedure, under all circumstances, is plainly stated in the “Book of Discipline,” which forms part of the Confession of Faith of our Church. The successive stages of discipline there unfolded are—(a) private admonition, (b) public admonition, (c) suspension, (d) excommunication.
(2.) The discipline should be wisely and justly proportioned “to the nature of the crime and demerit of the person.”
1 “What is Presbyterianism?” Rev. C. Hodge, D. D.