A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraphs 29.2–29.6

Chapter XXIX. Of the Lord’s Supper

The form in which the statements made in these Sections are put is rather negative than positive—rather designed to oppose certain Romish and Ritualistic errors than to make a simple statement of the true doctrine of the sacrament. The errors which are here opposed are—(1.) The doctrine of transubstantiation, or the change of the entire substance of the bread and wine into the body, blood, soul and divinity of the Lord Jesus. (2.) The sacrifice of the mass. (3.) The worshipping and reservation of the elements for any pretended religious use. (4.) Denying the cup to the laity. (5.) Private communion of the priest alone, or the sending of the elements to persons not present at the administration of the ordinance.

In order to make the statements of these Sections plain, we will first state the true doctrine (1) as to what elements and actions are essential to the sacrament, and (2) as to the true relation between the sign and the grace signified; and secondly, present the opposing papal errors upon the points above stated.

1st. The true doctrine (1) as to the elements. These are—(a.) Bread. This is essential, because it is in the command, and because bread as the staff of life for the body is the proper symbol of that spiritual food that nourishes the soul. Christ instituted the supper at the passover, when the only bread at hand was unleavened. The early Church always used the common bread of daily life. The Romish and Lutheran churches hold that unleavened bread should be used; the Reformed churches have uniformly held that the bread intended, and that best fulfils the conditions of the symbol, is the common bread of daily life—not the sweet cake used in so many of our old churches. (b.) Wine—that is, ὀ͂ινος, the fermented juice of the grape. Matt. ix. 17; John ii. 3–10; Rom. xiv. 21; Eph. v. 18; 1 Tim. iii. 8; v. 23; Titus ii. 3. This is made essential by the command and example of Christ, and by the uniform custom of the Christian Church from the beginning.

(2.) As to the sacramental actions which are essential to this ordinance. (a.) The consecration. This includes the repetition of the words of Christ used in the institution, together with a prayer in which the divine blessing is invoked upon the worshippers in the use of the ordinance, and so much of the elements as shall be used in the sacrament set apart from a common to a sacred use. (See § iii. of this Chapter). The words which express this in the Scripture are ἐυχαριστέω (Luke xxii. 19), and ἐυλογέω (Matt. xxvi. 36), and (1 Cor. x. 16). (b.) The breaking of bread. This is symbolical of the rending of Christ’s body on the cross, and of all the communicants being many feeding upon one Christ, as upon one bread. It is particularly mentioned in every account given of the institution by the evangelists. Matt. xxvi. 26; Mark xiv. 22; Luke xxii. 19; 1 Cor. xi. 24. See 1 Cor. x. 16. In Acts ii. 42 the whole ordinance is designated from this constituent action.

(c.) The distribution and reception of the elements. This is an essential part of the ordinance, which is not completed when the minister consecrates the elements, nor until they are actually received and eaten and drunk by the people. Christ says: “This do ye, in remembrance of me.” Paul adds, “For as oft as ye eat this bread and drink this cup, ye do show the Lord’s death till he comes.” So that the essence of the sacrament consists in the eating and the drinking.

2d. The papal errors condemned in these Sections are (1) their doctrine of transubstantiation or conversion of substance. The Council of Trent teaches, sess. xiii. cans. 1–4, that the whole substance of the bread is changed into the literal body, and the whole substance of the wine is changed into the literal blood of Christ, so that only the appearance or sensible properties of the bread and wine remain, and the only substances present are the true body and blood, soul and divinity of our Lord. And thus he is objectively presented to and is eaten and drunk by every recipient, believer and unbeliever indifferently, and thus he remains before and after the communion, his very body and blood, Godhead and manhood shut up in a vessel, carried about, elevated, worshipped, etc.

The Lutherans hold that while the bread and the wine remain, nevertheless at the words of consecration the real body and blood of Christ, though invisible, are really present in, with and under the bread and wine.

The only ground of this doctrine is the word of our Lord, “This is my body.” They hold the word “is” is literal; all the Reformed churches hold it must mean “represents,” “symbolizes.” This is a frequent usage of the word in Scripture. “The seven good kine are the seven years, and the seven good ears are the seven years.” Gen. xli. 26, 27; Ezek. xxxvii. 11; Dan. vii. 24; Luke xii. 1; Rev. i. 20. Besides, when our Lord said this and gave them the bread to eat, he was sitting by them in his sound, undivided flesh, eating and drinking with them.

This doctrine, then, is false—(a) because it is not taught in Scripture; (b) because it confounds the very idea of sacrament, making the sign identical with the thing it signifies. (c.) It contradicts our senses, since we see, smell, taste and feel bread and wine, and do never either see or smell or taste or feel flesh and blood. (d.) It contradicts reason, for reason teaches that qualities cannot exist except as they inhere in some substance, and that substance cannot be known and cannot act except by its qualities. But this doctrine supposes that the qualities of bread and wine remain without any substance, and that the substance of flesh and blood remains without any qualities. (e.) It is absurd and impossible, because Christ’s glorified body is still material, and therefore finite, and therefore not omnipresent in all places on earth, but absent at the right hand of God in heaven.

(2.) Their doctrine as to the mass as a sacrifice. The Council of Trent teaches (sess. xxii., cans. 1–3) that the Eucharist is both a sacrament and a sacrifice. As a sacrament, the soul of the recipient is nourished by the real body, blood, soul and divinity of Christ, which he eats in the form of a wafer. As a sacrifice, it is “an external oblation of the body and blood of Christ offered to God in recognition of his supreme lordship under the appearance of bread and wine visibly exhibited by a legitimate minister, with the addition of certain prayers and ceremonies prescribed by the Church, for the greater worship of God and edification of the people.”1 This is not a mere act in commemoration of the one sacrifice upon the cross, but a constantly-repeated real, although bloodless, expiatory sacrifice, atoning for sin and propitiating God.2

This doctrine is false, because (a) it is nowhere taught in Scripture. (b.) The Christian ministry are never called or spoken of as priests, but as “teachers” and “rulers.” (c.) The one sacrifice of Christ on the cross was perfect, and excludes all others. Heb. ix. 25–28; x. 10–27. (d.) The same ordinance cannot be both a sacrament and a sacrifice. Christ says that by eating and drinking we are “to show forth his death,” and “to do this in remembrance of him.” The same act cannot be a commemoration of one sacrifice, and itself an actual sacrifice having intrinsic sin-expiating efficacy.

(3.) Since the Papists hold that the entire substance of the bread and wine is permanently changed into the body, blood, soul and divinity of Christ, they consequently maintain that the principal intention of the ordinance is accomplished when the words of consecration are pronounced and the change effected. Hence they preserve the host carefully shut up in the pyx, elevate and adore and carry it about in their processions.

All this stands or falls with the doctrine of transubstantiation, before refuted.

(4.) After the establishment of the doctrine of transubstantiation, there arose the natural fear lest some of the august person of the Lord should be spilt or lost from the crumbling of the bread or the spilling of the wine. Hence the bread is prepared in little wafers which cannot crumble, and the cup is denied to the laity and confined to the priests. To comfort the laity they teach as the blood is in the flesh, and as the soul is in the body, and as the divinity is in the soul of Christ, that the whole person—body, blood, soul and divinity—of Christ is equally in every particle of the bread, so that he who receives the bread receives all.3

(5.) In opposition to the manifold abuses of this ordinance which prevail among the Romanists, our Standards, in common with the general judgment of the Reformed churches, teach that the Lord’s Supper is essentially a communion, in which the fellowship of the believer with Christ and with his fellow-believers is set forth by their eating and drinking of the same bread and the same cup. It follows that it should not be sent to persons not present at the administration, nor administered by the officiating priest to himself alone. In particular cases, however, it may be administered in private houses for the benefit of Christians long confined by sickness, provided that the officers and a sufficient number of the members of the church be present to preserve the true character of the ordinance as a communion.

1 Dens, vol. v., p. 358.

2 Council Trent, sess. xxii., can. 3.

3 Council of Trent, sess. xxi., cans. 1–3.