Paragraph 1.6
Chapter I. Of the Holy Scripture
This section teaches the following propositions:
1st. The inspired Scriptures of the Old and New Testament are a complete rule of faith and practice; they embrace the whole of whatever supernatural revelation God now makes to men, and are abundantly sufficient for all the practical necessities of men or communities.
This is proved (a) from the design of Scripture. It professes to lead us to God. Whatever is necessary to that end it must teach us. If any supplementary knowledge is necessary, it must refer to it. Incompleteness in such an undertaking would be falsehood. But (b) while Christ and his apostles constantly refer to Scripture as an authoritative rule, neither they nor the Scriptures themselves ever refer to any other source of divine revelation whatsoever. They therefore assume all the awful prerogatives of completeness. John xx. 31; 2 Tim. iii. 15–17. And (c), as a matter of fact, the Scriptures do teach a perfect system of doctrine, and all the principles which are necessary for the practical regulation of the lives of individuals, communities and churches. The more diligent men have been in the study of the Bible, and the more assiduous they have been in carrying out its instructions into practice, the less has it been possible for them to believe that it is incomplete in any element of a perfect rule of all that which man is to believe concerning God, and of all that duty which God requires of man.
2d. Nothing during the present dispensation is to be added to this complete rule of faith, either by new revelations of the Spirit or traditions of men.
No new revelations of the Spirit are to be expected now, because (a) he has already given us a complete and all-sufficient rule; (b) because, while the Old Testament foretells the new dispensation, the New Testament does not refer to any further revelation to be expected before the second advent of Christ. They always refer to the “coming” or “appearance” of Christ as the very next supernatural event to be anticipated. (c.) As a matter of fact, no pretended revelations of the Spirit since the days of the apostles have borne the marks or been accompanied with the “signs” of a supernatural revelation. On the contrary, all that have been made public—as those of Swedenborg and the Mormons—are inconsistent with Scripture truth, directly oppose the authority of Scripture and teach bad morals; while private revelations have been professed only by vain enthusiasts, and are incapable of verification.
Traditions of men cannot be allowed to supplement Scripture as a rule of faith, because (a) the Scriptures, while undertaking to lead men to a saving knowledge of God, never once ascribe authority to any such a supplementary rule. (b.) Christ rebukes the practical observance of it in the Pharisees. Matt. xv. 3–6; Mark vii. 7. (c.) Tradition cannot supplement Scripture, because, while the latter is definite, complete and perspicuous, the former is essentially indeterminate, obscure and fragmentary. (d.) The only system of ecclesiastical tradition which pretends to rival the Scriptures as a rule of faith is that of the Roman Church, and her traditions are, many of them, demonstrably of modern origin; none can be traced to the apostolic age, much less to an apostolic origin; they are inconsistent with the clear teaching of Scripture and with the opinions of many of the highest authorities in that Church itself in past ages.
3d. Nevertheless, a personal spiritual illumination by the power of the Holy Ghost is necessary in every case for the practical and saving knowledge of the truth embraced in the Scriptures. This necessity does not result from any want of either completeness or clearness in the revelation, but from the fact that man, in a state of nature, is carnal, and unable to discern the things of the Spirit of God. Spiritual illumination differs from inspiration, therefore, (a) in that it conveys no new truths to the understanding, but simply opens the mind and heart of the subject to the spiritual discernment and appreciation of the truth already objectively presented in the Scriptures, and (b) in that it is an element in regeneration common to all the children of God, and not peculiar to prophets or apostles; (c) and hence, in that it is private and personal in its use, and not public.
4th. That, while the Scriptures are a complete rule of faith and practice, and while nothing is to be regarded as an article of faith to be believed, or a religious duty obligatory upon the conscience, which is not explicitly or implicitly taught in Scripture, nevertheless they do not descend in practical matters into details, but, laying down general principles, leave men to apply them, in the exercise of their natural judgment, in the light of experience and in adaptation to changing circumstances, as they are guided by the sanctifying influences of the Holy Spirit.
This liberty, of course, is allowed only within the limits of the strict interpretation of the principles taught in the Word, and in the legitimate application of those principles, and applies to the regulation of the practical life of the individual and of the Church in detailed adjustments to changing circumstances.