A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869), Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF

Paragraph 5.1

Chapter V. Of Providence

Since the eternal and immutable purpose of God has certainly predetermined whatsoever comes to pass, it follows that he must execute his own purpose not only in his works of creation, but likewise in his continual control of all his creatures and all their actions. This Section therefore teaches—

1st. That God having created the substances of which all things are composed out of nothing, having endued these substances with their respective properties and powers, and having out of them formed all things organic and inorganic, and endowed them severally with their respective properties and faculties, he continues to sustain them in being and in the possession and exercise of those properties during the entire period of their existence.

2d. That God directs all the actions of his creatures according to their respective properties and relations.

3d. That his providential control extends to all his creatures and all their actions of every kind.

4th. That his providential control is in all respects the consistent execution of his eternal, immutable and sovereign purpose.

5th. That the final end of his providence is the manifestation of his own glory.

1st. With regard to the question how God is concerned in upholding and preserving the things he has made, three different classes of opinion have prevailed:

(1.) Deists and Rationalists generally regard God as sustaining no other relation to his works than that of the first of a series of causes and effects. He is supposed to touch the creation only at its commencement, and having given to things a permanent independent being exterior to himself, he leaves them to the unmodified exercise of their own faculties.

(2.) Pantheists regard all the phenomena of the universe of every kind as merely the various modes of one universal absolute substance. The substance is one, the modes many; the substance abides, the modes rapidly succeed each other; the substance is God, the modes we call things. Some true Christian theologians have taken a view of the relation of God to the world which comes perilously near, if it does not coincide with, this great pantheistic heresy. This view is that God’s power is constantly exerted in continually creating every individual thing again and again every fraction of duration; that created things have no real being of their own, and exist only as thus they are each moment the product of creative energy; and hence that the immediate cause of the state or action of any creature one moment of time is not its state or action the previous moment, but the direct act of divine creative power.

If this be so, it is plain that God is the only real agent in the universe; that he is the immediate cause of all things, including all evil passions and wicked thoughts and acts; that consciousness is a thorough delusion, and the free agency and moral accountability of man vain imaginations.

(3.) The third view is the true one, and it stands intermediate between the two above stated extremes. It may be stated as follows: (a.) God gave to all substances, both material and spiritual, a real and permanent existence as entities.

(b.) They really possess all such active and passive properties as God has severally endued them with.

(c.) These properties have a real and not merely an apparent efficiency as second causes in producing the effects proper to them.

(d.) But these created substances, although possessing a real existence exterior to God, and exerting real efficiency as causes, are not self-existent; that is, the ground of their continued existence is in God and not in them. Though not to be confounded with God, they are not to be separated from him, but “in him live and move, and have all their being.”

(e.) The precise nature of the exercise of divine energy whereby God interpenetrates the universe with his presence, embraces it and all things therein in his power and upholds them in being, is not revealed, and of course is indiscoverable.

That God always continues to exert his almighty power in upholding in being and in the possession and use of their endowments all things he has made is proved—

(1.) From the fact that continued dependence is inseparable from the idea of a creature. The abiding cause of the creature’s continued existence must ever be in God, as it is not in itself.

(2.) The relation of the creation to God cannot be analogous to that of a product of human skill to its maker. The one is exterior to his work. The intelligence and the power of the other is eternally omnipresent to every element of his work.

(3.) A sense of absolute dependence for continued being, power and blessedness is involved in the religious consciousness of all men.

(4.) It is explicitly taught in Scripture: “By him all things consist.” Col. i. 17; Heb. i. 3. “He upholds all things by the word of his power.” Heb. i. 3. “In him we live and move and have our being.” Acts xxvii. 28. “Oh bless our God, which holdeth our soul in life.” Ps. lxvi. 8, 9; lxiii. 8; xxxvi. 6.

2d. That God governs the actions of his creatures; and

3d. That his government extends to all his creatures and all their actions, is proved:

(1.) By the fact that the religious nature of man demands the recognition of this truth. It is involved in the sense of dependence and of subjection to a moral government which is involved in all religious feeling, and is recognized in all religions.

(2.) It is evidenced in the indications of intelligence everywhere present in the operations of external nature. The harmony, the due proportion and the exquisite concurrence in action which continue among so many elements throughout ceaseless changes prove beyond question the presence of an intelligence embracing all and directing each.

(3.) The same is likewise indicated in the intelligent design evidently pursued in the developments of human history during long periods and throughout vast areas, and embracing myriads of agents. “That God is in history” is a conclusion of just science as well as a dictate of true religion.

(4.) The Scriptures abound in prophesies fulfilled and unfulfilled, and promises and threatenings. Many of these are not mere enunciations of general principles, but specific declarations of purpose with reference to his treatment of individuals conditioned upon their conduct. The fulfilment of these could not be left to the ordinary course of nature, since there is often no natural connection between what is threatened or promised and the conditions on which they are suspended. God must therefore, by a constant providential regulation of the system of things, execute his own word to his creatures.

(5.) The Scriptures explicitly declare that such a providential control is exerted (a) over the physical world [a] in general. Job xxxvii. 6–13; Ps. civ. 14; cxxxv. 6, 7; cxlvii. 15–18. [b] Individual events in the natural world, however trivial. Matt. x. 29. (b.) Over fortuitous events. Job v. 6; Prov. xvi. 33. (c.) Over the brute creation. Ps. civ. 21–27; cxlvii. 9. (d.) Over the general affairs of men. Job xii. 23; Isa. x. 12–15; Dan. ii. 21; iv. 25. (e.) Over the circumstances of individuals. 1 Sam. ii. 6, 7, 8; Prov. xvi. 9; James iv. 13–15. (f.) Over the free actions of men. Ex. xii. 36; Ps. xxxiii. 14, 15; Prov. xix. 21; xxi. 1; Phil. ii. 13. (g.) Over the sinful actions of men. 2 Sam. xvi. 10; Ps. lxxvi. 10; Acts iv. 27, 28. (h.) Especially all that is good in man, in principle or action, is attributed to God’s constant gracious control. Phil. ii. 13; iv. 13; 2 Cor. xii. 9, 10; Eph. ii. 10; Ps. cxix. 36; Gal. v. 22–25.

4th. That the providential control of all things by God is the consistent execution in time of his eternal and immutable purpose is evident (1) from the statement of the case. Since God’s eternal purpose relates to and determines all that comes to pass, and since it is immutable, his providential control of all things must be in execution of his purpose. And since his purpose is infinitely wise, righteous and benevolent, and absolutely sovereign (as shown above), his providential execution of the decree must possess the same characteristics. (2.) The same is explicitly declared in Scripture: “He worketh all things after the council of his own will.” Eph. i. 11; Isa. xxviii. 29; Acts xv. 18.

5th. It is evident that the chief design of God in his eternal purpose and in his works of creation must also be his chief end in all his providential dispensations. This has been shown above to be the manifestation of his own glory. It is also directly asserted as the final end of his providence. Rom. ix. 17; xi. 36.