A Commentary on the Confession of Faith (1869)
Archibald Alexander Hodge · PDF
Preface
During the sessions of the General Assembly of 1868 in Albany, the Author was honored with an invitation from the Rev. G. C. Heckman, D. D., pastor of the State Street Church in that city, to visit a large and intelligent class held every Sunday afternoon in the body of the church, and instructed in the Confession of Faith by the admirable elder and fellow-labourer in the gospel, E. P. Durant, Esq. In both design and success this exercise appeared worthy of universal emulation. Its design was to diffuse throughout the entire congregation a higher knowledge of divine things, and a more earnest and intelligent appreciation of the doctrines and doctrinal Standards of our own denomination, and to educate its best elements of every age in preparation for the inestimably important offices of ruling elder, Sabbath-school and Bible-class teacher, and lay-preacher, etc. Its success, as evidenced by the number, the character, the intelligent interest and the regular attendance of the members, was and is to the present time as astonishing as it is gratifying.
At that time the design of this “Commentary” on the Confession of Faith was conceived. It consists of an analysis of its Chapters and Sections, with proofs and illustrations of its teachings—with Questions appended for the convenience of both the learner and teacher. It is in no sense controversial. It aims to bring out into full relief the natural, obvious and generally-admitted sense of the text. Its design is simply to stimulate and facilitate the study of this eminent embodiment of Christian truth, among Bible-class scholars, theological students, ruling elders and ministers. To all of these classes it is respectfully commended.
Great honour has recently been put upon the common Standards of the great Presbyterian family of churches. At the present time two great denominations, having discarded all defining clauses, seem likely to unite upon the basis of these “Standards, pure and simple.” We hail this with pleasure, and gratefully anticipate a largely increased interest in and study of these Standards on every side. This humble “Commentary” is not designed to forestall this study by partial interpretations in the interests of a party. It has been written with a sincere desire to promote such study in an impartial spirit, and to set forth these Standards in their plain, native sense before the eyes and for the admiration of all those of every name who so cordially love them, and are now so enthusiastically rallying around them.
A. A. H.
Allegheny City, Pa., April 30, 1869.
- Paragraph 1.1
This section affirms the following propositions: 1st. That the light of nature, and the works of creation and providence are sufficient to make known the fact that there is a God, and somewhat of his nature and…
- Paragraphs 1.2–1.3
These sections affirm the following propositions: 1st. That the complete canon of Scripture embraces in the two great divisions of the Old and the New Testaments all the particular books here named. 2d. That the books…
- Paragraphs 1.4–1.5
This section teaches the following propositions: 1st. That the authority of the inspired Scriptures does not rest upon the testimony of the Church, but directly upon God. This proposition is designed to deny the Romish…
- Paragraph 1.6
This section teaches the following propositions: 1st. The inspired Scriptures of the Old and New Testament are a complete rule of faith and practice; they embrace the whole of whatever supernatural revelation God now…
- Paragraph 1.7
This section affirms that the Scriptures are in such a sense perspicuous that all that is necessary for man to know, in order to his salvation or for his practical guidance in duty, may be learned therefrom, and that…
- Paragraph 1.8
This section teaches: 1st. That the Old Testament having been originally written in Hebrew and the New Testament in Greek, which were the common languages of the large body of the Church in their respective periods, the…
- Paragraphs 1.9–1.10
These sections teach: 1st. That the infallible and only true “rule” for the interpretation of Scripture is Scripture itself. 2d. That the Scriptures are the supreme “judge” in all controversies concerning religion. The…
- Questions
What propositions are affirmed in the first section? What is the first stated false opinion as to the capacity of men to attain to a knowledge of God? How is it proved to be false? What is the second false opinion…
- Paragraphs 2.1–2.2
These sections teach the following propositions: 1st. There is but one living and true God. 2d. This God is a free personal Spirit, without bodily parts or passions. 3d. He possesses all absolute perfections in and of…
- Paragraph 2.3
Having before shown that there is but one living and true God, and that his essential properties embrace all perfections, this Section asserts in addition— 1st. That Father, Son and Holy Ghost are each equally that one…
- Questions
What propositions are taught in the first and second Sections? To whom has the title God been applied? What two propositions are involved in the affirmation that there is but one living and true God? How may the truth…
- Paragraphs 3.1–3.2
These Sections affirm the following propositions: 1st. God has had from eternity an unchangeable plan with reference to his creation. 2d. This plan comprehends and determines all things and events of every kind that…
- Paragraphs 3.3–3.5
The preceding Sections having affirmed that the eternal, sovereign, immutable, unconditional decree of God determines all events of every class that come to pass, these Sections proceed to affirm, by way of…
- Paragraph 3.6
This section affirms: 1st. That although the decree of God is one eternal, all comprehensive intention, the several elements embraced within it necessarily sustain the relation to one another of means to ends. In…
- Paragraph 3.7
This Section teaches the following propositions: 1st. That as God has sovereignly destinated certain persons, called the elect, through grace to salvation, so he has sovereignly decreed to withhold his grace from the…
- Paragraph 3.8
This Section teaches that the high mystery of predestination is to be handled with special prudence and care. This necessity arises from the fact that it is often abused, and that its proper use is in the highest degree…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first and second Sections? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? What is the sixth? How can it be shown that…
- Paragraph 4.1
Compare with this Section, Larger Catechism questions 15 and 16. This Section teaches: 1st. That neither the world (the visible universe) nor anything therein is either, as to substance or form, self-existent or…
- Paragraph 4.2
Compare this Section with chapter vi., §§ 1 and 3, and L. Cat., Q. 17, and S. Cat., Q. 10. This Section teaches: 1st. That, last of all the inhabitants of this earth, man was created immediately by God. 2d. That God…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first Section? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What obvious distinction is to be made as to the two stages of creation?…
- Paragraph 5.1
Since the eternal and immutable purpose of God has certainly predetermined whatsoever comes to pass, it follows that he must execute his own purpose not only in his works of creation, but likewise in his continual…
- Paragraphs 5.2–5.3
These Sections teach: 1st. That as the execution of an eternal and sovereign purpose, God’s providential control is in the case of every being and event certainly efficacious. 2d. That the manner in which he controls…
- Paragraph 5.4
This Section makes no attempt to explain the nature of those providential actions of God which are concerned in the origin of sin in the moral universe, and in the control of the sinful actions of his creatures in the…
- Paragraphs 5.5–5.7
We have seen that the providential government of God, as the execution through time of his eternal and immutable purpose, forms one connected system, and comprehends all created things and all their actions. In perfect…
- Questions
How does God execute his decrees? What is the first proposition taught in the first Section? What is the second there taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? What is the rationalistic view as…
- Paragraph 6.1
God having brought the souls of Adam and Eve into being by immediate creation holy, and with sufficient knowledge as to his will, capable of obedience yet fallible, this Section proceeds to teach: 1st. That they sinned.…
- Paragraph 6.2
This Section teaches what were the consequences of this first sin upon its immediate authors. In doing so it affirms— 1st. That by this sin they were immediately cut off from communion with God. 2d. That consequently…
- Paragraphs 6.3–6.4
These Sections teach us what were the consequences of the first sin to the descendants of its authors. In doing so our standards affirm— 1st. That Adam was both the natural and federal head of all mankind. Conf. Faith,…
- Paragraphs 6.5–6.6
These Sections speak of the corruption that remains in the regenerated, and of the guilt or just liability to punishment which attaches to all sin, and of the punishments God inflicts upon them. I. Of the first, it is…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first Section? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? What appears to be God’s general plan of dealing with all…
- Paragraphs 7.1–7.2
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. The duty which an intelligent creature owes its Creator is essential and inalienable from its being. 2d. The enjoyment of the Creator’s fulness and love by the…
- Paragraphs 7.3–7.4
Since Adam forfeited for himself and his entire race the original promise of life upon the condition of perfect obedience, and incurred the penalty of death attached to disobedience, it follows that, if the old…
- Paragraphs 7.5–7.6
These Sections teach— 1st. That the covenant of grace has from the beginning remained in all essential respects the same, in spite of all outward changes in the mode of its administration. 2d. That under the old…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first and second Sections? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? Prove that the duty which an intelligent…
- Paragraph 8.1
We have already learned— 1st. That God has from eternity sovereignly chosen a definite number out of the fallen human race to be saved by means of the redemptive work of Christ. Conf. Faith, ch. iii., §§ 3–6. 2d. That…
- Paragraph 8.2
The subject of this Section is the constitution of the Person of the Mediator as the God-man. Having proved before (Chapter ii., § 3) that Jesus Christ is the one God, and that he is the second Person of the adorable…
- Paragraphs 8.3–8.4
These Sections proceed to teach— 1st. That the effect of this hypostatical union upon the human nature of Christ, although not deification, is an incomparable exaltation and glorification. 2d. That Christ is Mediator,…
- Paragraphs 8.5–8.6
Compare Chapter xi., § 3: “Christ, by his obedience and death, did fully discharge the debt of all those that are thus justified, and did make a proper, real and full satisfaction to his Father’s justice in their…
- Paragraph 8.7
Under Section ii. we saw that (a) Jesus of Nazareth was a true man. (b.) That he was true God. (c.) That he was nevertheless one single Person. (d.) That his personality is eternal and divine, his human nature having…
- Paragraph 8.8
This Section teaches— 1st. That Christ, as mediatorial King, seated at the right hand of God, applies the redemption he had effected as Priest to the proper subjects of it. This point has been already discussed under…
- Questions
What is the first truth before taught which is reaffirmed in the first Section? What is the second truth before taught which is here reaffirmed? What is the first additional proposition taught in this Section? What is…
- Paragraph 9.1
This Section teaches the great fundamental truth of consciousness and revelation, which renders moral government possible; that man, in virtue of his creation, is endowed with an inalienable faculty of…
- Paragraphs 9.2–9.5
These Sections briefly state and contrast the various conditions which characterize the free agency of man in his four different estates of innocency, hereditary sin, grace and glory. In all these estates man is…
- Questions
What is taught in the first Section? What view as to the nature of human agency is first stated above? What is the second view stated above? What is the true view? Prove that the first stated view is not true. In what…
- Paragraphs 10.1–10.2
There is an outward call of God’s word extended to all men to whom the gospel is preached, which is considered under the fourth Section of this chapter. The first and second Sections treat of the internal effectual call…
- Paragraph 10.3
The outward call of God’s word and all the “means of grace” provided in the present dispensation of course presuppose intelligence upon the part of those who receive them. The will of God, also, is revealed only as far…
- Paragraph 10.4
This Section, taken in connection with the parallel passage in L. Cat., Q. 60, teaches the following propositions: 1st. That the non-elect will certainly fail of salvation, not because a free salvation is not made…
- Questions
What two “calls” are spoken of in the Scriptures? Which “call” is treated of in the first and second Sections? What is the first proposition here affirmed on the subject of the internal call by the Holy Ghost? What is…
- Paragraphs 11.1–11.2
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. All those and only those whom God has effectually called he also freely justifies. 2d. This justification is a purely judicial act of God as Judge, whereby he…
- Paragraph 11.3
The first truth asserted in this Section is, that Christ, by his obedience and death, has fully paid the debt of those who are justified, and that he made for them a proper, real and full satisfaction to his Father’s…
- Paragraph 11.4
It has been objected to our doctrine by some Arminians, and held as a part of it by some Antinomians, that if Christ literally paid the debt of his elect in his obedience and suffering when on earth, it must follow that…
- Paragraph 11.5
This Section teaches that justification changes radically and permanently the relation which the subject of it sustains both to God and to the demands of the divine law, viewed as a condition of favour. Before…
- Paragraph 11.6
The truth taught in this Section has already been fully proved above, under Chapter vii., §§ 4, 5 and 6; and Chapter viii., § 6.
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first and second Sections? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? What is the sixth? How can you prove that God…
- Paragraph 12.1
The instant a believer is united to Christ in the exercise of faith, there is accomplished in him simultaneously and inseparably two things: (1.) A total change of relation to God, and to the law as a covenant of life;…
- Questions
What is the subject of this Chapter? What two changes take effect instantly upon the act of faith? What is regeneration? What is faith and its relation to regeneration? What is justification and its relation to faith?…
- Paragraphs 13.1–13.3
This Chapter teaches the following propositions: 1st. All of those in whom God has by regeneration created a new spiritual nature continue under his gracious influence, his Word and Spirit dwelling in them, and thus…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in this Chapter? What is the second proposition here taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? In what different senses is the term “to sanctify” used in…
- Paragraph 14.1
Faith, in the most general sense of the word, is the assent of the mind to the truth of that of which we have not an immediate cognition; knowledge is the perception of the truth of that of which we have an immediate…
- Paragraph 14.2
This Section teaches— 1st. That saving faith rests upon the truth of the testimony of God speaking in his word. 2d. That it respects as its object all the contents of God’s word, without exception. 3d. That the complex…
- Paragraph 14.3
In this Section it is affirmed— 1st. That this faith, although always as to essence the same, is often different in degrees in different persons, and in the same person at different times. 2d. That it is exposed to many…
- Questions
What is the most general sense of the word “faith?” What is knowledge, and how does it differ from faith? Prove that faith is not irrational, and that it rests upon appropriate evidence. Show that faith is exercised by…
- Paragraphs 15.1–15.2
These Sections teach the following truths: 1st. That as to the grounds of it, true evangelical repentance rests upon (a) a true sense of the guilt, pollution and power of his own sinfulness, and of his own sinful deeds;…
- Paragraphs 15.3–15.5
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. That repentance is not to be rested in, as any satisfaction for sin or any cause of the pardon thereof. 2d. That, nevertheless, it is of such necessity that it is…
- Paragraph 15.6
This Section teaches— 1st. That every man should make private confession of all his sins to God, and that God will certainly pardon him when his sorrow and his renunciation of his sins are sincere. This is all included…
- Questions
What is the first truth taught in the first and second Sections? What is the second taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What does a true sense of sin include? Show how it leads to repentance. Show that an…
- Paragraphs 16.1–16.2
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. In order that any human action should be truly a good work, it must have the following essential characteristics: (1.) It must be something directly or implicitly…
- Paragraph 16.3
As we have seen under Chapter x., in regeneration the Holy Spirit implants a permanent holy principle or habit in the soul which ever continues the germ or seed from which all gracious affections and holy exercises do…
- Paragraphs 16.4–16.6
These Sections teach— 1st. That works of supererogation are so far from being possible, even for the most eminent saint, that in this life it is not possible for the most thoroughly sanctified one fully to discharge all…
- Paragraph 16.7
This Section teaches— 1st. That unregenerate men may perform many actions which, for the matter of them, are such as God commands, and are of good use both to themselves and others. The truth of this is verified in the…
- Questions
What are taught in the first and second Sections to be the essential characteristics of every truly good work? What is there taught us as to the effects and uses of good works? State the proof derived from the nature of…
- Paragraphs 17.1–17.3
This Chapter teaches the following propositions: 1st. The true believer, having been once regenerated and justified by God, can never afterward totally nor finally fall away from grace, but shall certainly persevere…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in this Chapter? What is the difference between falling totally and finally? Why must Arminians and Calvinists take opposite sides on this question? What is the Arminians’ doctrine…
- Paragraphs 18.1–18.2
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. There is a false assurance of salvation which unregenerate men sometimes indulge, in which they are deceived and which shall be finally disappointed. 2d. There is,…
- Paragraphs 18.3–18.4
These Sections teach— 1st. That this infallible assurance is not of the essence of faith—that on the contrary a man may be a true believer and yet destitute of this assurance. 2d. That being, nevertheless, as taught in…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in Sections i. and ii.? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third? What reason have we for believing that a spurious assurance is possible to the unregenerated?…
- Paragraphs 19.1–19.2
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. That God, as the supreme moral Governor of the universe, introduced the human race into existence as an order of moral creatures, under inalienable and perpetual…
- Paragraphs 19.3–19.5
These Sections teach— 1st. That besides the moral law summarily expressed in the Decalogue, God gave the Jews a ceremonial law, wherein, by means of types and symbols, (a) Christ and his work were set forth, and (b)…
- Paragraphs 19.6–19.7
In these Sections it is affirmed— 1st. That since the fall no man is able to attain to righteousness and eternal life through obedience to the law. This is beyond question, because all men have sinned; because men’s…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first two Sections? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third taught? What is the fourth taught? Why is it certain that at his creation God placed man…
- Paragraph 20.1
The subject of this Chapter is that liberty wherewith Christ makes his people free, which is very different from that freedom of the will which we discussed under Chapter ix. We there saw that freedom of the will is an…
- Paragraphs 20.2–20.4
These Sections teach the following propositions: 1st. God alone is Lord of the human conscience, which is responsible only to his authority. 2d. God has authoritatively addressed the human conscience only in his law,…
- Questions
What is the subject of this Chapter? How does it differ from that of Chapter ix.? What is implied in Christian liberty? In what two aspects is this liberty set forth in this Chapter? What several particulars are…
- Paragraphs 21.1–21.2
These Sections teach— 1st. That the obligation to render supreme worship and devoted service to God is a dictate of nature as well as a doctrine of revelation. 2d. That God in his word has prescribed for us how we may…
- Paragraphs 21.3–21.4
Our Confession having established the general truth as to the object to whom religious worship is to be rendered, and as to the source of our knowledge of its nature and proper methods, now proceeds to state more…
- Paragraphs 21.5–21.6
These Sections proceed to particularize the different ways in which God requires us under the present dispensation to worship him. These are the regular and the occasional acts of worship. The regular worship of God is…
- Paragraphs 21.7–21.8
Under Chapter xix. we saw that the different laws of God, when classified according to their respective grounds or reasons, might be grouped as follows: (1.) Those having their ground in the divine nature, and therefore…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first and second Sections? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third there taught? What is the fourth there taught? Show that it is a dictate of natural…
- Paragraphs 22.1–22.4
The subjects treated of in these Sections are—(a.) The nature of a lawful oath. (b.) The only name in which it is lawful to swear. (c.) The propriety and duty of taking oaths upon the proper occasions. (d.) The sense in…
- Paragraphs 22.5–22.7
The vow is a promise made to God. In the oath, the parties are both men, and God is invoked as a witness. In the vow, God is the party to whom the promise is made. It is of like nature with an oath, because we are bound…
- Questions
What are the subjects treated of in the first four Sections of this Chapter? What is a lawful oath? What is implied in it, and how is this implication generally expressed? Show how the oath is an act of religious…
- Paragraphs 23.1–23.2
These Sections teach as follows: 1st. Civil government is a divine institution, and hence the duty of obedience to our legitimate rulers is a duty owed to God, as well as to our fellow-men. Some have supposed that the…
- Paragraphs 23.3–23.4
These Sections teach that the Church and the State are both divine institutions, having different objects and spheres of action, different governments and officers, and hence, while owing mutual good offices, are…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first and second Sections of this Chapter? What has by some been presumed to be the ultimate foundation of civil government? State the proof, from the general facts of God’s…
- Paragraphs 24.1–24.3
It is taught in these Sections— 1st. That marriage was ordained of God, and is therefore a divine institution, involving a religious as well as a civil contract. 2d. The ends designed to be promoted by marriage are…
- Paragraphs 24.4–24.6
These Sections teach the divine law of marriage as to incest and as to divorce. 1st. Incest consists of sexual intercourse between parties forbidden by the divine law to marry, because of their relationship. Marriage…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first three Sections of this Chapter? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third there taught? What is the fourth there taught? What is the fifth there…
- Paragraphs 25.1–25.3
The word catholic means universal, and therefore is the proper title of the true Church of Christ, viewed as one body, composed of many members, existing in different places and at different times, and is consequently…
- Paragraphs 25.4–25.6
All that is taught in these Sections necessarily follows from what we have above ascertained as to the nature of the visible Church: 1st. Since the catholic or universal visible Church consists of all the professors of…
- Questions
What is the true sense and right application of the word “catholic?” What is the etymology and usage of the word translated “church” in the New Testament? Prove that it is the invisible spiritual Church to which the…
- Paragraphs 26.1–26.3
Communion is a mutual interchange of offices between parties which flows from a common principle in which they are united. The nature and degree of the communion will depend upon the nature and intimacy of the union…
- Questions
What is communion, and what does it presuppose? What is the first subject taught in these Sections? What is the second subject here taught? What is the third? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? What is the…
- Paragraphs 27.1–27.2
The word sacrament does not occur in the Scriptures. In its classical usage it designated anything which binds or brings under obligations, as a sum of money given in pledge, or an oath, and especially the oath of…
- Paragraph 27.3
Having asserted that the sacraments actually confer the grace which they represent to worthy recipients, our Confession in this Section proceeds to guard this important truth from abuse, by carefully showing upon what…
- Paragraph 27.4
As we have seen, the word sacrament was used very indefinitely in the early Church to include any religious rite which had a latent spiritual meaning. A pre-eminence was always awarded to Baptism and the Lord’s Supper…
- Paragraph 27.5
We saw, under Chapter vii., §§ 5 and 6, that the old and new dispensations were only two different modes in which the one changeless covenant of grace was administered and its blessings dispensed. The sacramental seals…
- Questions
What was the classical usage of the word sacrament? What was the early ecclesiastical usage of the word? On what principles, therefore, are we to form our definition of a sacrament? What is the first point involved in…
- Paragraphs 28.1–28.3
In these Sections we are taught the following propositions: 1st. Baptism is a sacrament of the New Testament, instituted immediately by Christ, and by his authority to continue in the Church until the end of the world.…
- Paragraph 28.4
As to the subjects of baptism, our Standards teach— 1st. As to adults, “Baptism is not to be administered to any that are out of the visible Church, and so strangers from the covenant of promise, till they profess their…
- Paragraphs 28.5–28.7
These Sections teach— 1st. That grace and salvation are not so inseparably united to baptism that only the baptized are saved, or that all the baptized are saved. 2d. That, nevertheless, it is a great sin to contemn or…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first three Sections of this Chapter? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third proposition there taught? What was the origin of ceremonial washing, and…
- Paragraph 29.1
This Section teaches us—(a.) Of the time in which, and the person by whom, the Lord’s Supper was instituted. (b.) Of its perpetual obligation. (c.) Of its design and effect. 1st. Of the fact that it was instituted by…
- Paragraphs 29.2–29.6
The form in which the statements made in these Sections are put is rather negative than positive—rather designed to oppose certain Romish and Ritualistic errors than to make a simple statement of the true doctrine of…
- Paragraphs 29.7–29.8
These Sections teach the Reformed doctrine as to the relation which in the Lord’s Supper subsists between the sign and the grace signified—that is, as to the nature of the presence of Christ in the sacrament, and the…
- Questions
What are the subjects treated of in the first Section? State the evidence that this ordinance was instituted immediately by the Lord in person. State the proof that it was designed to be perpetually observed in the…
- Paragraph 30.1
The principle designated Erastianism, which has been practically embodied in all the State churches of the Old World, includes the following elements: (1.) That the Church is an organ of the State to accomplish one of…
- Paragraphs 30.2–30.4
These Sections teach— 1st. As to the nature and extent of the power conferred upon the Church of admitting and excluding from the fold, and of disciplining its members. 2d. As to the ends of this discipline. 3d. As to…
- Questions
What is the first point involved in the Erastian doctrine as to the relation of the Church to the State? What is the second point involved? What is the third? What is the first point in opposition to this heresy taught…
- Paragraphs 31.1–31.2
As we have seen in the last Chapter, all Church power is vested by Christ in the Church as a whole, not as a mob, but as an organized body. As organized, the Church consists of presbyters or bishops and the people, and…
- Paragraphs 31.3–31.5
These Sections state—(1.) The different subjects which come before these church courts for decision. (2.) The grounds upon which, and the conditions under which, their decisions are to be regarded as requiring…
- Questions
In whom has Christ vested all Church power? Through whose agency do the people exercise the powers inherent in them? To what body does this necessarily give rise? In whom does the governing power in each congregation…
- Paragraph 32.1
This Section teaches— 1st. That man consists of two distinct elements, a soul and a body, and that death consists in their temporary separation. 2d. That while the body is resolved into its constituent chemical…
- Paragraphs 32.2–32.3
These Sections teach— 1st. That at the last day there will be a simultaneous resurrection of all the dead, both of the just and of the unjust. 2d. That those who then remain living on the earth shall not die, but be…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first Section? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third proposition there taught? What is the fourth? What is the fifth? Prove that Scripture takes the…
- Paragraphs 33.1–33.2
These Sections teach— 1st. That God has appointed a day of general judgment. 2d. That he has committed this judgment into the hands of the God-man in his character as Mediator. 3d. That the persons to be judged include…
- Paragraph 33.3
This Section teaches— 1st. That God has made the fact absolutely certain that there will be a future judgment, in order that this knowledge may act upon all men as a wholesome motive deterring them from sin, and, at the…
- Questions
What is the first proposition taught in the first and second Sections of this Chapter? What is the second proposition there taught? What is the third proposition there taught? What is the fourth proposition? What is the…
Introduction
Chapter I. A Short History of Creeds and Confessions
It is asserted in the first chapter of this Confession, and vindicated in this exposition that the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, having been given by inspiration of God, are for man in his present state the only and the all-sufficient rule of faith and practice. All that man is to believe concerning God, and the entire duty which God requires of man, are revealed therein, and are to be believed and obeyed because contained therein, because it is the word of God. This divine word, therefore, is the only standard of doctrine which has intrinsic authority binding the conscience of men. And all other standards are of value or authority only in proportion as they teach what the Scriptures teach.
While, however, the Scriptures are from God, the understanding of them belongs to the part of men. Men must interpret to the best of their ability each particular part of Scripture separately, and then combine all that the Scriptures teach upon every subject into a consistent whole, and then adjust their teachings upon different subjects in mutual consistency as parts of a harmonious system. Every student of the Bible must do this, and all make it obvious that they do it by the terms they use in their prayers and religious discourse, whether they admit or deny the propriety of human creeds and confessions. If they refuse the assistance afforded by the statements of doctrine slowly elaborated and defined by the Church, they must make out their own creed by their own unaided wisdom. The real question is not, as often pretended, between the word of God and the creed of man, but between the tried and proved faith of the collective body of God’s people, and the private judgment and the unassisted wisdom of the repudiator of creeds.
As we would have anticipated, it is a matter of fact that the Church has advanced very gradually in this work of the accurate interpretation of Scripture and definition of the great doctrines which compose the system of truth it reveals. The attention of the Church has been specially directed to the study of one doctrine in one age, and of another doctrine in another age. And as she has thus gradually advanced in the clear discrimination of gospel truth, she has at different periods set down an accurate statement of the results of her new attainments in a Creed or Confession of Faith, for the purpose of preservation and popular instruction. In the mean time, heretics spring up on all occasions, who pervert the Scriptures, who exaggerate certain aspects of the truth and deny others equally essential, and thus in effect turn the truth of God into a lie. The Church is forced, therefore, on the great principle of self-preservation, to form such accurate definitions of every particular doctrine misrepresented as shall include the whole truth and exclude all error, and to make such comprehensive exhibitions of the system of revealed truth as a whole that no one part shall be either unduly diminished or exaggerated, but the true proportion of the whole be preserved. At the same time, provision must be made for ecclesiastical discipline, and to secure the real co-operation of those who profess to work together in the same cause, so that public teachers in the same communion may not contradict one another, and the one pull down what the other is striving to build up. Formularies must also be prepared, representing as far as possible the common consent, and clothed with public authority, for the instruction of the members of the Church, and especially of the children.
Creeds and Confessions, therefore, have been found necessary in all ages and branches of the Church, and, when not abused, have been useful for the following purposes: (1.) To mark, disseminate and preserve the attainments made in the knowledge of Christian truth by any branch of the Church in any crisis of its development. (2.) To discriminate the truth from the glosses of false teachers, and to present it in its integrity and due proportions. (3.) To act as the basis of ecclesiastical fellowship among those so nearly agreed as to be able to labor together in harmony. (4.) To be used as instruments in the great work of popular instruction.
It must be remembered, however, that the matter of these Creeds and Confessions binds the consciences of men only so far as it is purely scriptural, and because it is so; and as to the form in which that matter is stated, they bind those only who have voluntarily subscribed the Confession, and because of that subscription.
In all churches a distinction is made between the terms upon which private members are admitted to membership, and the terms upon which office-bearers are admitted to their sacred trusts of teaching and ruling. A Church has no right to make anything a condition of membership which Christ has not made a condition of salvation. The Church is Christ’s fold. The sacraments are the seals of his covenant. All have a right to claim admittance who make a credible profession of the true religion—that is, who are presumptively the people of Christ. This credible profession of course involves a competent knowledge of the fundamental doctrine of Christianity—a declaration of personal faith in Christ and consecration to his service, and a temper of mind and habit consistent therewith. On the other hand, no man can be inducted into any office in any Church who does not profess to believe in the truth and wisdom of the constitution and laws which it will be his duty to conserve and administer. Otherwise all harmony of sentiment and all efficient co-operation in action would be impossible.
The original Synod of our American Presbyterian Church in the year 1729 solemnly adopted the Westminster Confession of Faith and Catechisms as the doctrinal standards of the Church. The record is as follows:
“All the ministers of the Synod now present, which were eighteen in number, except one, that declared himself not prepared, [but who gave his assent at the next meeting], after proposing all the scruples any of them had to make against any articles and expressions in the Confession of Faith, and Larger and Shorter Catechisms of the Assembly of Divines at Westminster, have unanimously agreed in the solution of those scruples, and in declaring the said Confession and Catechisms to be the Confession of their Faith, except only some clauses in the twentieth and twenty-third chapters, ‘Concerning the Civil Magistrate.’”
Again, in the year 1788, preparatory to the formation of the General Assembly, “the Synod, having fully considered the draught of the Form of Government and Discipline, did, on review of the whole, and hereby do, ratify and adopt the same, as now altered and amended, as the Constitution of the Presbyterian Church in America, and order the same to be considered and strictly observed as the rule of their proceedings, by all the inferior judicatories belonging to the body.
“The Synod, having now revised and corrected the draught of a Directory for Worship, did approve and ratify the same, and do hereby appoint the same Directory, as now amended, to be the Directory for the worship of God in the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America. They also took into consideration the Westminster Larger and Shorter Catechisms, and, having made a small amendment of the Larger, did approve and do hereby approve and ratify the said Catechisms, as now agreed on, as the Catechisms of the Presbyterian Church in the United States. And the Synod order that the Directory and Catechisms be printed and bound up in the same volume with the Confession of Faith and the Form of Government and Discipline; that the whole be considered as the standard of our doctrine, government, discipline and worship, agreeably to the resolutions of the Synod at their present session.”
What follows is a very brief and general history of the principal Creeds and Confessions of the several branches of the Christian Church. In this statement they are grouped according to the order of time and the churches which adhere to them:
I. The ancient Creeds, which express the common faith of the whole Church.
The Creeds formed before the Reformation are very few, relate to the fundamental principles of Christianity, especially the Trinity and the Person of the God-man, and are the common heritage of the whole Church.
1st. The Apostles’ Creed. This was not written by the apostles, but was gradually formed, by common consent, out of the Confessions adopted severally by particular churches, and used in the reception of its members. It reached its present form, and universal use among all the churches, about the close of the second century. This Creed was appended to the Shorter Catechism, together with the Lord’s Prayer and Ten Commandments, in the first edition published by order of Parliament, “not as though it were composed by the apostles, or ought to be esteemed canonical Scripture, . . . but because it is a brief sum of Christian faith, agreeable to the Word of God, and anciently received in the churches of Christ.” It was retained by the framers of our Constitution as part of the Catechism.1 It is as follows:
“I believe in God the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth; and in Jesus Christ his only Son our Lord; who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead, and buried; he descended into hell (Hades); the third day he rose again from the dead, he ascended into heaven, and sitteth at the right hand of God the Father Almighty; from thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead. I believe in the Holy Ghost; the Holy Catholic Church; the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins; the resurrection of the body; and the life everlasting. Amen.”
2d. The Nicene Creed. This Creed is formed on the basis of the Apostles’ Creed, the clauses relating to the consubstantial divinity of Christ being contributed by the great Council held in Nice in Bithynia, A. D. 325, and those relating to the divinity and personality of the Holy Ghost added by the Second Œcumenical Council, held at Constantinople, A. D. 381; and the “filioque” clause added by the Council of the Western Church, held at Toledo, Spain, A. D. 569. In its present form it is the Creed of the whole Christian Church, the Greek Church rejecting only the last added clause. It is as follows:
“I believe in one God, Maker of heaven and earth, and all things visible and invisible; and in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Only begotten Son of God, begotten of his Father before all worlds; God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father; by whom all things were made; who, for us men and for our salvation, came down from heaven, and was incarnate by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary, and was made man, and was crucified also for us under Pontius Pilate. He suffered and was buried; and the third day he rose again according to the Scriptures, and ascended into heaven, and sitteth on the right hand of the Father. And he shall come again with glory to judge both the quick and the dead; whose kingdom shall have no end. And I believe in the Holy Ghost, the Lord the Giver of life, who proceedeth from the Father and the Son (filioque), who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified; who spake by the prophets. And I believe in one Catholic and Apostolic Church; I acknowledge one baptism for the remission of sins; and I look for the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come.”
3d. As subsequently heretical opinions sprang up in its bosom with respect to the constitution of the person of Christ, the Church was forced to provide additional definitions and muniments of the truth. One heretical tendency culminated in Nestorianism, which maintains that the divine and human natures in Christ constitute two persons. This was condemned by the Creed of the Council of Ephesus, A. D. 431. The opposite heretical tendency culminated in Eutychianism, which maintains that the divine and human natures are so united in Christ as to form but one nature. This was condemned by the Council of Chalcedon, A. D. 451. These Creeds, defining the faith of the Church as embracing two natures in one person, are received and approved by the entire Church. They are sufficiently quoted in the body of the following “Commentary.”
4th. The Athanasian Creed. This Creed was evidently composed long after the death of the great theologian whose name it bears, and after the controversies closed and the definitions established by the above-mentioned Councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon. It is a grand and unique monument of the unchangeable faith of the whole Church as to the great mysteries of godliness, the Trinity of Persons in the one God and the duality of natures in the one Christ. It is too long to quote here in full. What relates to the Person of the God-man is as follows:
“27. But it is necessary to eternal salvation that he should also faithfully believe in the incarnation of our Lord Jesus Christ. 28. It is therefore true faith that we believe and confess that our Lord Jesus Christ is both God and man. 29. He is God; generated from eternity from the substance of the Father; man born in time from the substance of his Mother. 30. Perfect God, perfect man, subsisting of a rational soul and human flesh. 31. Equal to the Father in respect to his divinity, less than the Father in respect to his humanity. 32. Who, although he is God and man, is not two, but one Christ. 33. But two not from the conversion of divinity into flesh, but from the assumption of his humanity into God. 34. One not at all from confusion of substance, but from unity of Person. 35. For as rational soul and flesh is one man, so God and man is one Christ,” etc.
II. The Creeds and Confessions of the different branches of the Church since the Reformation.
1st. The Doctrinal Standards of the Church of Rome.
In order to oppose the progress of the Reformation, Pope Paul III. called the last great Œcumenical Council at Trent (1545–1563). The deliverances of this Council, entitled Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent, form the highest doctrinal rule known to that Church. The decrees contain the positive statements of doctrine. The canons explain the decrees, distribute the matter under brief heads and condemn the opposing of Protestant doctrine on each point.
The Roman Catechism, which explains and enforces the canons of the Council of Trent, was prepared and promulgated by the authority of Pope Pius IV., A.D. 1556.
The Tridentine Confession of Faith was also imposed upon all the priests and candidates of the Romish Church and converts from other churches.
In addition to these, different papal bulls and some private writings have been authoritatively set up as standards of the true faith by the authority of popes; e. g., the Catechism of Bellarmine, A.D. 1603, and the bull Unigenitus of Clement XI., 1711.
The theology taught in all these papal standards is Arminianism.
2d. The Doctrinal Standards of the Greek Church.
The ancient Church divided from causes primarily political and ecclesiastical, secondarily doctrinal and ritual, into two great sections—the Eastern or Greek Church, and the Western or Latin Church. This division began to culminate in the seventh, and was consummated in the eleventh century. The Greek Church embraces Greece, the majority of the Christians of the Turkish Empire and the great mass of the civilized inhabitants of Russia. All the Protestant churches have originated through the Reformation from the Western or Roman Church.
This Church arrogates to herself pre-eminently the title of the “orthodox,” because the original creeds defining the doctrine of the Trinity and the Person of Christ, which have been mentioned above, were produced in the Eastern half of the ancient Church, and hence are in a peculiar sense her inheritance. Greek theology is very imperfectly developed beyond the ground covered by these ancient creeds, which that Church magnifies and maintains with singular tenacity.
They possess also a few confessions of more modern date, as “The Orthodox Confession” of Peter Mogilas, A.D. 1642, metropolitan bishop of Kiew, the Confession of Gennadius, A.D. 1453.
3d. The Confessions of the Lutheran Church.
The entire Protestant world from the time of the Reformation has been divided into two great families of churches—the Lutheran, including all those which received their characteristic impress from the great man whose name they bear; the Reformed, including all those, on the other hand, which derived their character from Calvin.
The Lutheran family of churches embraces all those Protestants of Germany and the Baltic provinces of Russia who adhere to the Augsburg Confession, together with the national churches of Denmark, of Norway and Sweden, and the large denomination of that name in America.
Their Symbolical Books are: (1.) The Augsburg Confession, the joint authors of which were Luther and Melancthon. Having been signed by the Protestant princes and leaders, it was presented to the emperor and imperial Diet in Augsburg A.D. 1530. It is the oldest Protestant confession, the ultimate basis of Lutheran theology, and the only universally accepted standard of the Lutheran churches.
(2.) The Apology (Defence) of the Augsburg Confession, prepared by Melancthon A.D. 1530, and subscribed by the Protestant theologians A.D. 1537 at Smalcald.
(3.) The Larger and Smaller Catechisms, prepared by Luther A.D. 1529, “the first for the use of preachers and teachers, the last as a guide in the instruction of youth.”
(4.) The Articles of Smalcald, drawn up by Luther A.D. 1536, and subscribed by the evangelical theologians in February, A.D. 1537, at the place whose name they bear.
(5.) The Formula Concordiæ (Form of Concord), prepared in A.D. 1577 by Andreä and others for the purpose of settling certain controversies which had sprung up in the Lutheran Church, especially (a) concerning the relative activities of divine grace and the human will in regeneration, (b) concerning the nature of the Lord’s presence in the Eucharist. This confession contains a more scientific and thoroughly developed statement of the Lutheran doctrine than can be found in any other of their public symbols. Its authority is, however, acknowledged only by the high Lutheran party; that is, by that party in the Church which consistently carries the peculiarities of Lutheran theology out to the most complete logical development.
4th. The Confessions of the Reformed or Calvinistic churches.
The Reformed churches embrace all those churches of Germany which subscribe the Heidelberg Catechism; the Protestant churches of Switzerland, France, Holland, England and Scotland: the Independents and Baptists of England and America, and the various branches of the Presbyterian Church in England and America.
The Reformed Confessions are very numerous, although they all substantially agree as to the system of doctrine they teach. Those most generally received, and regarded as of the highest symbolical authority as standards of the common system, are the following:
(1.) The Second Helvetic Confession, prepared by Bullinger, A. D. 1564. “It was adopted by all the Reformed churches in Switzerland, with the exception of Basle (which was content with its old symbol, the First Helvetic), and by the Reformed churches in Poland, Hungary, Scotland and France,”2 and has always been regarded as of the highest authority by all the Reformed churches.
(2.) The Heidelberg Catechism, prepared by Ursinus and Olevianus, A. D. 1562. It was established by civil authority, the doctrinal standard, as well as instrument of religious instruction for the churches of the Palatinate, a German State at that time including both banks of the Rhine. It was endorsed by the Synod of Dort, and is the Confession of Faith of the Reformed churches of Germany and Holland, and of the German and [Dutch] Reformed churches in America.
(3.) The Thirty-nine Articles of the Church of England. These were originally drawn up by Cranmer and Ridley, A. D. 1551, and revised and reduced to the present number by the bishops, at the order of Queen Elizabeth, A. D. 1562. These Articles are Calvinistic in doctrine, and constitute the doctrinal standard of the Episcopal churches in England, Scotland, America and the Colonies.
(4.) The Canons of the Synod of Dort. This famous Synod was convened in Dort, Holland, by the authority of the States General, for the purpose of settling the questions brought into controversy by the disciples of Arminius. It held its sessions from November 13, A. D. 1618, to May 9, A. D. 1619. It consisted of pastors, elders and theological professors from the churches of Holland, and deputies from the churches of England, Scotland, Hesse, Bremen, the Palatinate and Switzerland; the French delegates having been prevented from being present by order of their king. The Canons of this Synod were received by all the Reformed churches as a true, accurate and eminently authoritative exhibition of the Calvinistic System of Theology. They constitute, in connection with the Heidelberg Catechism, the doctrinal Confession of the Reformed Church of Holland, and of the [Dutch] Reformed Church of America.
(5.) The Confession and Catechisms of the Westminster Assembly. A short account of the origin and constitution of this Assembly, and of the production and reception of its doctrinal deliverances, is presented in the next chapter. This is the common doctrinal standard of all the Presbyterian churches in the world of English and Scotch derivation. It is also of all Creeds the one most highly approved by all the bodies of Congregationalists in England and America. The Congregational Convention called by Cromwell to meet at Savoy, in London, A. D. 1658, declared their approval of the doctrinal part of the Confession and Catechisms of the Westminster Assembly, and conformed their own deliverance, the Savoy Confession, very nearly to it. Indeed, “the difference between these two Confessions is so very small, that the modern Independents have in a manner laid aside the use of it (Savoy Conf.) in their families, and agreed with the Presbyterians in the use of the Assembly’s Catechisms.”3
All the Assemblies convened in New England for the purpose of settling the doctrinal basis of their churches have either endorsed or explicitly adopted this Confession and these Catechisms as accurate expositions of their own faith. This was done by the Synod which met at Cambridge, Massachusetts, June, 1647, and again August, 1648, and prepared the Cambridge Platform. And again by the Synod which sat in Boston, September, 1679, and May, 1680, and produced the Boston Confession. And again by the Synod which met at Saybrook, Connecticut, 1708, and produced the Saybrook Platform.4
Questions
- What is the only absolute and essentially authoritative standard of faith?
- Whence do all human Creeds derive their authority?
- Upon whom rests the necessity and obligation of gathering together all the Scripture teaches on any subject, and of adjusting their teaching on one subject with all the other elements of the system of truth?
- Is it better for a man to form these opinions without or with the assistance of the great body of his fellow-Christians?
- In what form have the opinions of the great mass of the Christian Church on these subjects been expressed and preserved?
- What then is the first great purpose for which Creeds and Confessions are useful?
- What is the second great end?
- What is the third?
- What is the fourth?
- On what ground, and how far does the matter of these Confessions bind the consciences of men?
- Whom and on what ground does the form of these Confessions bind?
- What are the terms upon which private members are admitted to the Church?
- What are the terms upon which preachers and rulers are admitted to office in the Church?
- Why should the terms be so far different in the two cases?
- When, and by what representative body of our Church, were the Westminster Confession and Catechisms first adopted as our standard of faith?
- Read the adopting act.
- Read the action of the General Synod, passed A. D. 1788.
- To what class of topics do all the Creeds before the Reformation relate?
- What is the origin of what is commonly called the Apostles’ Creed?
- Has it always had a place in our Catechism?
- Read it.
- When and by what Councils was the Nicene Creed produced?
- Read it.
- What opposite heretical tendencies, respecting the Person of Christ, subsequently sprang up in the Church?
- What was the date and design of the Creed of the Council of Ephesus?
- What was the date and design of the Creed of the Council of Chalcedon?
- What was the origin of the Creed falsely attributed to the great Athanasius?
- Read that portion of it which relates to the Person of Christ.
- What are the doctrinal standards of the Church of Rome?
- What is the character of the theology they teach?
- When, why, and into what divisions did the Church of the Middle Ages separate?
- What countries are embraced in the bounds of the Greek Church?
- What are the doctrinal standards of the Greek Church?
- Into what two great divisions did the churches of the Reformation separate?
- What is the common characteristic of the Lutheran churches?
- What is the common characteristic of the Reformed churches?
- What churches belong to the Lutheran family?
- What is the name, date and origin of their principal and universally-received standard of faith?
- What are their other symbolical books?
- What is the origin, purpose and character of the Form of Concord, and in what estimation is it held?
- What churches are embraced in the Reformed or Calvinistic family?
- What account is here given of the Second Helvetic Confession?
- What account is here given of the Heidelberg Catechism?
- Of what churches is it the accredited standard?
- What is here said of the Thirty-nine Articles of the Church of England?
- By whom, where, when and for what purpose was the Synod of Dort convened?
- Of what parties was it composed?
- In what estimation have its “Canons” been held, and of what churches are they the standard?
- Of what churches are the Westminster Confession and Catechisms the standard of faith?
- How far have they been adopted by the Congregationalists of England?
- Upon what occasions and to what extent have they been adopted by the Congregationalists of New England?
Chapter II. Some Account of the Origin of the Westminster Confession and Catechisms
Most of the Confessions of the Reformed and Lutheran churches were composed by single authors, or by a small group of theologians to whom the task of drawing up a standard of doctrine had been committed. Thus, Luther and Melancthon were the principal authors of the Augsburg Confession, the common standard of faith and bond of union of the Lutheran churches. The Second Helvetic Confession was composed by Bullinger, to whom the work was entrusted by a number of Swiss theologians; and the celebrated Heidelberg Catechism was composed by Ursinus and Olevianus, who had been appointed thereto by Frederick III., Crown Prince of the Palatinate. The Old Scotch Confession, which was the standard of the Presbyterian Church of Scotland for nearly one hundred years before the adoption of the Westminster Confession, was composed by a committee of six theologians, at the head of whom was John Knox, appointed by the Scottish Parliament. The Thirty-nine Articles of the Church of England and of the Episcopal Church of America were prepared by the bishops of that Church in 1562, as the result of the revision of “The Forty-two Articles of Edward Sixth,” which had been drawn up by Archbishop Cranmer and Bishop Ridley in 1551.
The “Canons of the Synod of Dort,” of high authority among all the Reformed churches, and the Standard of the Church of Holland, were on the other hand drawn up by a great international Synod convened in Dort by the States General of the Netherlands, and composed of representatives of all the Reformed churches except that of France. And the Confession of Faith and Catechisms of our Church were drawn up by a large and illustrious national assembly of divines and civilians convened in Westminster, England, by the Long Parliament from July 1, 1643, to February 22, 1648; a very brief account of which it is the design of this chapter to give.
The Reformation in Scotland had received its first impulse from the return of the illustrious Patrick Hamilton, in 1528, from the Continent, where he had enjoyed the instructions of Luther and Melancthon. It was in no degree a political revolution, nor did it originate with the governing classes. It was purely a religious revolution, wrought among the masses of the people and the body of the Church itself, under the direction at different times of several very eminent leaders, the chief of whom were John Knox and Andrew Melville. “The Church of Scotland framed its Confession of Faith and its First Book of Discipline, and met in its first General Assembly for its own government, seven years before it had even received the sanction of the legislature. Its first General Assembly was held in 1560, while the first Act of Parliament recognizing it as the National Church was passed in 1567.”5 It continued to maintain in a good degree its independence of civil dictation and its integrity as a Presbyterian Church until after King James assumed the throne of England. After that time, through English influence and the increased power of the throne, the independence of the Church of Scotland was often temporarily destroyed. In resistance to this invasion of their religious liberties, the friends of liberty and of the Reformed religion among the Scotch nobility, clergy and people, signed the ever-memorable National Covenant at Sterling, February 28, 1638, and the Solemn League and Covenant between the kingdoms of England and Scotland in 1643. “This Solemn League and Covenant (subscribed by the Scotch General Assembly, the English Parliament and Westminster Assembly) bound the united kingdoms to endeavour the preservation of the Reformed religion in the Church of Scotland, in doctrine, worship, discipline and government, and the reformation of religion in the kingdoms of England and Ireland, according to the Word of God and the example of the best Reformed churches.”6 It was in furtherance of the same design of securing in both kingdoms religious liberty, a more perfect reformation and ecclesiastical uniformity, that the Scotch people gave the effective support of their sympathy to the English Parliament in their struggle with Charles I., and that the Scottish Church sent her most eminent sons as delegates to the Westminster Assembly.
The Reformation in England presents two distinct phases—that of a genuine work of grace, and that of a political and ecclesiastical revolution. In the former character it was introduced by the publication of the Word of God, the Greek Testament of Erasmus, published in Oxford, 1517, and the English translation of the Bible by Tyndal, which was sent over from Worms to England in 1526. By the English Bible, together with the labours of many truly pious men both among the clergy and laity, a thoroughly popular revolution was wrought in the religion of the nation, and its heart rendered permanently Protestant. The real Reformers of England, such as Cranmer, Ridley, Hooper, Latimer and Jewell, were truly evangelical and thoroughly Calvinistic, in full sympathy and constant correspondence with the great theologians and preachers of Switzerland and Germany. This is illustrated in their writings, in the Forty-two Articles of Edward VI., 1551, the present doctrinal Articles of the Church of England, prepared in 1562, and even in the Lambeth Articles, drawn up by Archbishop Whitgift as late as 1595.
Although this work of genuine reformation was in the first instance materially aided by the politico-ecclesiastical revolution introduced by Henry VIII. and confirmed by his daughter, Queen Elizabeth, it was nevertheless greatly impeded and prematurely arrested by it. “The Act of Supremacy,” which made the sovereign the earthly head of the Church, and subjected all questions of doctrine, church order and discipline to his absolute control, enabled Elizabeth to arrest the constitutional changes in the Church set up by the process of reform at that precise point which was determined by her worldly taste and her lust of power. An aristocratic hierarchy naturally sided with the Court, and became the facile instrument of the Crown in repressing both the religious and civil liberties of the people. Gradually the struggle between the party called Puritan and the repressive Court party became more intense and more bitter during the whole period of the reigns of James I. and Charles I. A new element of conflict was introduced in the fact that the despotic Court party naturally abandoned the Calvinism of the founders of the Church, and adopted that Arminianism which has always prevailed among the parasites of arbitrary power and the votaries of a churchly and sacramental religion.
The denial of all reform, and the unrelenting execution of the “Act of Uniformity,” repressing all dissent while robbing the people of every trace of religious liberty, necessarily led to such an extension of the royal prerogative, and such constant resort to arbitrary measures and acts of violence, that the civil liberties of the subject were equally trampled under foot. At last, after having for an interval of eleven years attempted to govern the nation through the Star Chamber and Court of High Commission, and having prorogued the refractory Parliament which met in the spring of that year, the king was forced to appeal again to the country, which sent up in November, 1640, that illustrious body subsequently known as the Long Parliament. In the May of the next year this body rendered itself practically independent of the king’s caprice by passing an act, providing that it should be dissolved only at its own consent, and at the same time all the members of both houses, except two of the peers, subscribed a bond binding them to persevere in the defence of their liberties and of the Protestant religion. In the same year Parliament abolished the Court of High Commission and the Star Chamber; and in November, 1542, it was ordained that after November 5, 1543, the office of archbishop and bishop, and the whole framework of prelate government, should be abolished.
In June 12, 1643, the Parliament passed an act entitled “An ordinance of the Lords and Commons in Parliament, for the calling of an Assembly of Divines and others, to be consulted with by the Parliament for the settling of the government and liturgy of the Church of England, and clearing of the Doctrine of said Church from false aspersions and interpretations.” As the pre-existing government of the Church by bishops had ceased to exist, and yet the Church of Christ in England remained, the only universally recognized authority which could convene the representatives of the Church in General Assembly was the National Legislature. The persons who were to constitute this Assembly were named in the ordinance, and comprised the flower of the Church of that age; subsequently about twenty-one clergymen were superadded to make up for the absence of others. The original list embraced the names of ten lords and twenty commoners as lay-members, and one hundred and twenty-one divines. Men of all shades of opinion as to Church government were embraced in this illustrious company—Episcopalians, Presbyterians, Independents and Erastians. “In the original ordinance four bishops were named, one of whom actually attended on the first day, and another excused his absence on the ground of necessary duty; of the others called, five became bishops afterward, and about twenty-five declined attending, partly because it was not a regular convocation called by the king, and partly because the Solemn League and Covenant was expressly condemned by his majesty.”7 The Scotch General Assembly also sent as delegates to Westminster the best and ablest men she had—ministers Alexander Henderson, the author of the Covenant, George Gillespie, Samuel Rutherford and Robert Baillie; and elders Lord John Maitland and Sir Archibald Johnston.
Only sixty appeared the first day, and the average attendance during the protracted sittings of the Assembly ranged between sixty and eighty. Of these the vast majority were Presbyterians, after the Episcopalians had withdrawn subsequently to the signing of the Solemn League and Covenant. The vast majority of the Puritan clergy, after the example of all the Reformed churches of the Continent, were inclined to Presbyterianism, and in many places, especially in the city of London and its neighbourhood, had erected presbyteries.
There were only five prominent Independents in the Assembly, headed by Dr. Thomas Goodwin and Rev. Philip Nye. These were called, from the attitude of opposition to the majority which they occupied, “The Five Dissenting Brethren.” In spite of the smallness of their number, they possessed considerable influence in hindering, and finally preventing, the Assembly in its work of national ecclesiastical construction, and their influence was due to the support they received from politicians without the Assembly, in the Long Parliament, in the army, and, above all, from the great Cromwell himself.
The Erastians, who held that Christian pastors are simply teachers and not rulers in the Church, and that all ecclesiastical as well as all civil power rests exclusively with the civil magistrate, were represented in the Assembly by only two ministers—Thomas Coleman and John Lightfoot, assisted actively by the learned layman, John Selden. Their influence was due to the fact that the Parliament sympathized with them, and as a matter of course all worldly politicians.
The prolocutor, or moderator, appointed by the Parliament, was Dr. Twisse, and after his death he was succeeded by Mr. Herle. On the 1st of July, 1643, the Assembly, after hearing a sermon from the prolocutor in the Abbey Church, Westminster, was organized in Henry the VII.’s Chapel. After the weather grew cold they met in the Jerusalem Chamber, “a fair room in the Abbey of Westminster.” When the whole Assembly had been divided for despatch of business into three equal committees, they took up the work which was first assigned to them by Parliament—namely, the revision of the “Thirty-nine Articles,” the already existing Creed of the English Church. But on the 12th of October, shortly after subscribing the Solemn League and Covenant, Parliament directed the Assembly “to consider among themselves of such a discipline and government as may be most agreeable to God’s holy word.” They consequently entered immediately upon the work of preparing a Directory of Government, Worship and Discipline. Being delayed by constant controversies with the Independent and Erastian factions, they did not complete this department of their work until near the close of 1644. Then they began to prepare for the composition of a Confession of Faith, and a committee was appointed to prepare and arrange the main propositions to be embraced in it. This committee consisted of the following persons: Dr. Hoyle, Dr. Gouge and Messrs. Herle, Gataker, Tuckney, Reynolds and Vines.
The committee at first wrought at the work of preparing the Confession and Catechisms simultaneously. “After some progress had been made with both, the Assembly resolved to finish the Confession first, and then to construct the Catechism on its model.” They presented in a body the finished Confession to Parliament, December 3, 1646, when it was recommitted, that the “Assembly should attach their marginal notes, to prove every part of it by Scripture.” They finally reported it as finished, with full Scripture proofs of each separate proposition attached, April 29, 1647.
The Shorter Catechism was finished and reported to Parliament November 5, 1647, and the Larger Catechism April 14, 1648. On the 22d of March, 1648, a conference was held between the two Houses, to compare their opinions respecting the Confession of Faith, the result of which is thus stated by Rushworth:
“The Commons this day (March 22d), at a conference, presented the Lords with a Confession of Faith passed by them, with some alterations (especially concerning questions of discipline), viz.: That they do agree with their Lordships, and so with the Assembly, in the doctrinal part, and desire the same may be made public, that this kingdom, and all the Reformed churches of Christendom, may see the Parliament of England differ not in doctrine.”8
The Confession of Faith, Directory of Public Worship and the Larger and Shorter Catechisms were all ratified by the Scotch General Assembly as soon as the several parts of the work were concluded at Westminster.
On October 13, 1647, the Long Parliament established the Presbyterian Church in England experimentally, “until the end of the next session of Parliament, which was to be a year after that date.” But before that date the Parliament had become subservient to the power of the army under Cromwell. Presbyteries and synods were soon superseded by his Committee of Triers, while the Presbyterian ministers were ejected in mass by Charles II. in 1662.
After the completion of the Catechisms, many of the members quietly dispersed and returned to their homes. “Those that remained in London were chiefly engaged in the examination of such ministers as presented themselves for ordination or induction into vacant charges. They continued to maintain their formal existence until the 22d of February, 1649, about three weeks after the king’s decapitation, having sat five years, six months and twenty-two days, in which time they had held one thousand one hundred and sixty-three sessions. They were then changed into a committee for conducting the trial and examination of ministers, and continued to hold meetings for this purpose, every Thursday morning, until March 25, 1652, when, Oliver Cromwell having forcibly dissolved the Long Parliament, by whose authority the Assembly had been at first called together, that committee also broke up, and separated without any formal dissolution, and as a matter of necessity.”
The Confession of Faith and Larger and Shorter Catechisms of the Westminster Assembly were adopted by the original Synod in North America, A. D. 1729, as the “Confession of Faith of this Church,” and it has been received as the standard of faith by all the branches of the Presbyterian Church in Scotland, England, Ireland and America; and it is highly reverenced, and its Catechisms used as means of public instruction, by all the Congregational bodies of Puritan stock in the world.
Although the Westminster Assembly resolutely excluded from their Confession all that they recognized as savouring of Erastian error, yet their opinions as to church establishments led to views concerning the powers of civil magistrates, concerning religious things (circa sacra), which have always been rejected in this country. Hence, in the original “Adopting Act,” the Synod declared that it did not receive the passages relating to this point in the Confession “in any such sense as to suppose the civil magistrate hath a controlling power over synods with respect to the exercise of their ministerial authority; or power to persecute any for their religion, or in any sense contrary to the Protestant succession to the throne of Great Britain.”
And again, when the Synod revised and amended its standards in 1787, in preparation for the organization of the General Assembly in 1789, it “took into consideration the last paragraph of the twentieth chapter of the Westminster Confession of Faith; the third paragraph of the twenty-third chapter, and the first paragraph of the thirty-first chapter; and, having made some alterations, agreed that the said paragraphs as now altered be printed for consideration.” As thus altered and amended, this Confession and these Catechisms were adopted as the doctrinal part of the Constitution of the Presbyterian Church in America in 1788, and so stand to this day.
The original Articles of the Westminster Confession as to the civil magistrate which are altered in our Confession are as follow:
Westm. Conf., chap. 20, § 4, of certain offenders it is said: “They may be proceeded against by the censures of the Church and by the power of the civil magistrate.” Chap. 23, § 3: “The civil magistrate may not assume to himself the administration of the Word and sacraments, or the power of the keys of the kingdom of heaven; yet he hath authority, and it is his duty, to take order that unity and peace be preserved in the Church; that the truth of God be kept pure and entire; that all blasphemies and heresies be suppressed, all corruptions and abuses in worship and discipline prevented or reformed, and all ordinances of God duly settled, administered and observed. For the better effecting whereof, he hath power to call synods, to be present at them, and to provide that whatsoever is transacted in them be according to the mind of God.” Chap. 31, § 2: “As magistrates may lawfully call a synod of ministers and other fit persons to consult and advise with about matters of religion, so, if magistrates be open enemies to the Church, the ministers of Christ of themselves, by virtue of their office, or they with other fit persons upon delegation from their churches, may meet together in such assemblies.”
Questions
- How were most of the Confessions of the Lutheran and Reformed churches composed?
- What is peculiar in the case of the Canons of the Synod of Dort and the Confession and Catechisms of Westminster?
- State the general character of the Reformation in Scotland.
- What were the character and design of the Solemn League and Covenant, and by what parties was it contracted?
- What was the general character of the Reformation in England?
- What was the principal instrumentality by which the work was effected?
- What was the character of the theology, and what the direction of the sympathies, of the early English Reformers?
- What was the character of the influence exerted upon the English Reformation by her first Protestant sovereigns?
- What proved to be the civil effects of the attempt upon the part of the Crown to repress religious liberty?
- State some of the first acts of the Long Parliament.
- When and for what purpose was the Assembly of Divines called at Westminster?
- What was the number and what was the character of the persons composing that Assembly?
- Who were the representatives of the Scotch Church?
- Into what three principal parties were the members of this Assembly divided? and to which party did the vast majority of the Assembly belong?
- How was the Assembly organized?
- What was the first work performed by the Assembly?
- When and how did they proceed to frame a Confession of Faith?
- How did they proceed to frame the Catechisms?
- What was the action of the Long Parliament touching the work of the Assembly?
- What the action of the Scotch General Assembly as to the same?
- What was the ultimate fate of the Presbyterian establishment in England?
- Of what churches is the Westminster Confession the Constitutional Standard of Doctrine?
- When and with what exceptions was this Confession adopted by the Presbyterian Church in America?
- When and why and in what sections was it amended?
1 Assembly’s Digest, p. 11.
2 Shedd’s Hist. of Christian Doctrine.
3 Neal: Puritans, II. 178.
4 Shedd’s Hist. of Christian Doctrine.
5 Hetherington’s “History of the Westminster Assembly,” p. 88.
6 Hetherington’s “History of the Church of Scotland,” p. 187.
7 Hetherington’s “History of the Westminster Assembly,” p. 99.
8 Hetherington’s “Hist. Westminster Assembly,” p. 245.
Source: The Presbyterian Board of Publication’s first edition, 821 Chestnut Street, [1869] (the Library of Congress’s copy) (PDF)